Hartlett replacement

[quinny88]

Have to use my last trade on this  ::)

Have narrowed it down to these 4!

Edit: Thompson out for the season so have taken him off the poll

[Vinny]

Never thought I would say this but, stay away from McKenzie for now.

I haven't watched many GC games lately and I'm not sure if his role has changed but his scores haven't been good.

I liked the look of Birchall last week. Hope he doesn't spud now I've suggested him but that's my pick.

:)

[Jroo]

Never thought I would say this but, stay away from McKenzie for now.

I haven't watched many GC games lately and I'm not sure if his role has changed but his scores haven't been good.

I liked the look of Birchall last week. Hope he doesn't spud now I've suggested him but that's my pick.

:)

I agree, McKenzie has been terrible in his last two weeks and I wouldn't bring him in.
I like Birchall too, he probably won't be tagged as well, which is why he produced some poor scores earlier in the year.

[Holz]

if you have guts, hanley if he plays will probably outscore these 3.

[Ringo]

Have you looked at Bob Murphy for last 2 games Quinny - Brisbane this week and melbourne next week.

[Rusty00]

Out of these 3 I would pick Thompson (providing of course he makes the cut this week. McKenzie can't be trusted at the moment and I think Birchall will cop some attention the next couple of weeks.

[billnats]

From the one's listed I will say Birchall... but I don't trust the man.
I am going for Hibberd. Gladly take his 80-120 range compared to Birchall/Murphy's 60-110 range.

[geoffmack]

How much money you have? I have same problem/challenge this week. Ellis playing GWS this week could b an option. Bob Murphy as well!

[quinny88]

if you have guts, hanley if he plays will probably outscore these 3.

Already have Hanley. Sorry I should mention my other defenders are Gibbs, Goddard, Shaw, Hanley, Heppell, ?? (Grimes, Staker)
Obviously wont have to do the trade if one of Heppell or Hanley play but I doubt they will

Have you looked at Bob Murphy for last 2 games Quinny - Brisbane this week and melbourne next week.

Can't quite afford him or I would have for sure

[quinny88]

How much money you have? I have same problem/challenge this week. Ellis playing GWS this week could b an option. Bob Murphy as well!

$491,100

Ellis is tempting!  Hadn't thought of him. Gws and then the out of form Essendon

[ben_020285]

Already have Hanley. Sorry I should mention my other defenders are Gibbs, Goddard, Shaw, Hanley, Heppell, ?? (Grimes, Staker)
Obviously wont have to do the trade if one of Heppell or Hanley play but I doubt they will[/quote]

I don't think you'll need to use the trade mate. Heppell is definitely out but Hanley is very likely to play so you should have 6 defenders available this week.

[Holz]

If your going to trade (hanley should play)

it has to be for this guy.

94 average

116 115 102 92 90 88 for a 101 average in his last 6. playing sydney is a slight worry but he is probably the most underated back in SC. I should have picked him over cannon.

Corey Enright.

[tkringle]

Have you looked at Bob Murphy for last 2 games Quinny - Brisbane this week and melbourne next week.

+1

[Colty]

If your going to trade (hanley should play)

it has to be for this guy.

94 average

116 115 102 92 90 88 for a 101 average in his last 6. playing sydney is a slight worry but he is probably the most underated back in SC. I should have picked him over cannon.

Corey Enright.

I thought Enright as well but I was thinking if round 23 is a dead rubber and cats cant go up and down the ladder he may be rested?

[quinny88]

Well I can cross Scott Thompson off the list, he's out for the rest of the season.

Holz, enright is someone I did briefly look at, I guess I figured he doesn't have the big ceiling though that could win me the GF and just a slight concern he could be rested in the last round before finals perhaps? Then again you're ranked #2 so maybe I should just listen to you :P hopefully Hanley gets up and I don't have to do the trade at all!