Making cash but still Scoring High

Started by NastyPenguin, March 08, 2010, 08:07:21 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

NastyPenguin

Backs: Goddard, Hodge, Dempsey, Malcheski, Hunt, Greenwood, Maguire. (Moore, Sheppard)

Mids: Ablett, Bartel, Dal Santo, Mitchell, Zaharakis, Martin. (Barlow, Banner)

Rucks: Tippett, Hille. (McEvoy, Currie)

Forwards: Reiwoldt, Brown, Franklin, Gray, Hall, Dangerfield, Gumbleton.(Hitchcock, Davis.P)

* 40k still in the bank.
**Rookies are subject to change

Critique away  ;D

Big_Cox14

Alright I'll critique away.
Backs: Quite a solid backline. Not sure if Maguire is necessarily best 22. I would prefer to have him as a bench player myself and possibly upgrade one of Moore or Sheppard.
Mids: Excellent midfield. I like Zaharakis as a unique player.
Rucks: Lot of upside there. McEvoy could prove to be excellent bench cover if one of King or Gardiner gets injured.
Forwards: I like the forward line, but think its risky starting Gumbleton with his history of injuries.
Overall, a pretty solid side with a few risks and a few unique players. I rate it a 8/10. 

lowedown11

to many premium mids wen there are plenty un gun rookie mids to choose from...like ur rucks wouldn hav start gumbleton or maguire n maybe missing one more gun backman.... overall 6/10


RICHOO

Ablett will drop in price.

Bartel is more of a dream team player. good get better value out of mitchell or boyd or selwood

gumbleton. stupit playing him, he will get injuryed or wont play, so if you down grade a little mid field(ablett) maby bartel, get a good young forward, eg mayne( freo) it would look like a unstopeable team.

NastyPenguin

Waters > Gilbee
Bartel > Ball
Ablett > Selwood
Gumbleton > Rohan

Dal Santo > Captain