Who to Bench?

Started by turry17, August 15, 2013, 04:05:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

turry17

Have two queries of who to bench in my mids and fowards

Mids are Swan, Ablett, Pendlebury, Selwood, Jack, Barlow, Cotchin, Montagna (Watson, Hunter)
Watsons there because I just traded him in but I'm not sure if he should stay on the bench?

Also tossing up between Cloke, Bartel and JJK. Have to bench one of those

Cheers

popedelio

With your forwards, Collingwood is hitting form so I would definitely start Cloke. So really it's battle between JJK and Bartel. I guess JJK, he had down week because he didn't kick many goals. Where as Bartel you just don't know where he is going to play, so to me that is a bigger risk, so JJK over Bartel.

On your mids, seriously don't know who to bench or start, I guess its just a matter of preference

turry17

Yeah JJK was benched last week so might go with that again. Might just close my eyes and choose one in my mids, honestly no idea

m_zulian

JJK will find it tough against the Geelong defence with a high of 72 in his 7 games against them.
Tough one for your mids. Similar to my mids with your 7 starters same as mine.
Start Watson. he averages 113.3 in his last 3 vs Kan
I assume it's Jelwood rather than Scooter. Although he doesn't have the best record against the Eagles with an average of 89.3 and only 2 tons in his 7 games against them, he is in super form, tackling and kicking goals.
In my opinion, it comes down to Montagna vs Jack. In their past 3 against their opposition Jack averages 103.6 vs Stk and Montagna averages 103.3 vs Syd. It's very close..Jack has scored 1 more point.
Sydney is Montagnas worst opponent. He only averages 78.7 against Sydney. So, I would bench Montagna