Hypothetical

[Mailman the 2nd]

What in the world makes you think Tom Boyd will be a megastar in his first two seasons?

[ossie85]

There is still no way the Giants would give you there #1 pick for McPharlin. Argument is mute! Freo would have to give more....

[Ricochet]

We would not win a flag without McPharlin. He's probably in the top 2 of our most important players
And I can't see the Giants giving up pick 1 for a guy with only a couple of seasons left

[valkorum]

Ricochet - McPharlin isn't "probably" in our best 2.  He is our most important player.

[Ricochet]

A fit McPharlin is right next to a fit Pav and a fit Sandi imo. Yes we can win games without them, but all three are dominant when fit.