Who are the weakest links? (PIC)

Started by ADEZ, August 12, 2013, 02:45:33 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who are the weakest points?

McKenzie
Stanton
Goldstein
Bartel

ADEZ



McKenzie
last 5: 87, 111, 60, 69, 53
Run home: PA, Stk, GWS
Possible replacement: Ibbo to Hanley (last 5 = 100) has GWS, WB and Geelong, McKenzie to bench...
Thoughts: has been very poor of late but has an awesome run home, With Paul Stewart out for Port, There will be next to no chance of a forward tag

Stanton
Last 5: 107, 80, 89, 73, 100
Run home: NM, Carlton, Richmond
Possible Replacement: Stanton to Griffen (133 and 121 in last two, ADE, BL and MELB) to come OR Murphy to Watson, Stanton to bench
Thoughts: Although he has been poor lately, he looked to be getting his groove back last week slutting it up with 1-2's...has scored huge against NM (153), Carlton (175) and Richmond (144) over this year and last year

Goldstein
Last 5: 72, 73, 137, 74, 57
Run home: Essendon, Hawks, Collingwood
Possible Replacement: Minson has been awesome, ADE, BL, and Melb to come
Thoughts: Goldy has been poor lately, his huge year as the number one ruck has started to catch up on him, Minson looks a perfect swap

Bartel
Last 5: 76, 69, 66, 90, 55
Run home: WCE, Sydney, BL
Possible replacement: Buddy to Roo? has Syd, GC, Freo, scored 150 this year against Sydney but that's a tough run home!, Henderon maybe? has WB, Melb, WCE but still unsure on him
Thoughts: Bartel has a terrific record against WCE at Paterson, but a good record doesn't change a non-Dt relevant defensize role.....but maybe after Angus kicked 7 on him last week he won't be put on another play like him, in this case LeCras...or he'll put more work into his defensive game  :o

So who do I trade out?
at this stage thinking Ibbo to Hanley and Goldy to Minson, will still have McKenzie on bench in case he fires again

LF

I'd hold Bartel he has a pretty go record v Eagles
I'd try to get Cannon to the bench and trade Ibbo even if he plays he hasn't been very good since McPharlin got injured.
Tough one between Stants and Goldy
Do you have enough cash to trade Murphy and then move Stants to your bench?
I have Goldy and I see the rucks as the lowest point gain so I'm not trading Goldy yet myself I'm trying to gain more points in my backs and mids.

ADEZ

Quote from: luvfooty on August 12, 2013, 03:15:39 PM
I'd hold Bartel he has a pretty go record v Eagles
I'd try to get Cannon to the bench and trade Ibbo even if he plays he hasn't been very good since McPharlin got injured.
Tough one between Stants and Goldy
Do you have enough cash to trade Murphy and then move Stants to your bench?
I have Goldy and I see the rucks as the lowest point gain so I'm not trading Goldy yet myself I'm trying to gain more points in my backs and mids.

Cheers for the feedback...
I can trade Ibbo to Hanley and Murphy to Scooter/Montagna/Watson OR Ibbo to Ellis and Murphy to Griffen

Legoman

Ellis could be a good unique. Has had some large scores this season when fit. Looking at his stats he gets a lot of loose ball with heaps of marks.

ADEZ

Quote from: Legoman on August 12, 2013, 03:24:33 PM
Ellis could be a good unique. Has had some large scores this season when fit. Looking at his stats he gets a lot of loose ball with heaps of marks.
Yeah I really like Ellis, has a terrific work ethic...has Carlton, GWS and Essendon, tends to score big against weaker opponents but still solid against the better ones, I doubt he'll get a tag from GWS, runs too hard

TMurphBROWNLOW

Ibbo to Hanley and then do Murphy to Watson!