HELP! Kreuzer to Minson/Sandi???

[dcmagadia21]

I'm going to work soon and have to do my trades now. To get Minsob or Sandi? Minson could smash it with Carlton not having a real ruckman this week or get Sandi who's facing GWS and has the potential to smash. SEND HELP!

[Artax]

Minson man. That's what I've done.

BELIEVE!

[Jormas]

Minson for this week.... Sandi for the rest of the season..

Sandi > Minson. IMO another 10 ppg average.

[jamfrank]

Minson this week for sure. Playing under a roof, whereas it's likely to rain here in Perth on Sunday...

[smoothM24]

Would you boys get Minson over Roughead aswell ?

[jamfrank]

Would you boys get Minson over Roughead aswell ?

most definitely

[pommyadam]

Minson this week for sure. Playing under a roof, whereas it's likely to rain here in Perth on Sunday...

not sure that logic follows
surely rain = more stoppages = more hitouts = more points

[Sweetness]

Minson this week for sure. Playing under a roof, whereas it's likely to rain here in Perth on Sunday...

not sure that logic follows
surely rain = more stoppages = more hitouts = more points

+1 My thinking as well

[Dasherman]

I was going to keep Kruz and trade Nicholls to Maric giving me Cox Maric (Kreuzer, Grundy) I want to keep Kruz long term but if he's out for a while than maybe Minson????

[jamfrank]

Minson this week for sure. Playing under a roof, whereas it's likely to rain here in Perth on Sunday...

not sure that logic follows
surely rain = more stoppages = more hitouts = more points

Makes it difficult for the big men to mark it, and also slower getting around...less ball. Probably get 50 hit outs, but less chance of getting a heap more

[Possumo]

Minson for this week.... Sandi for the rest of the season..

Sandi > Minson. IMO another 10 ppg average.

Pretty sure Minson has been smashing it all season, whereas Sandi is just coming back from a long injury layoff, and hasn't been scoring that well at all...

Definitely happy I brought in Minson this week myself :)

[henry]

Minson for this week.... Sandi for the rest of the season..

Sandi > Minson. IMO another 10 ppg average.

Pretty sure Minson has been smashing it all season, whereas Sandi is just coming back from a long injury layoff, and hasn't been scoring that well at all...

Definitely happy I brought in Minson this week myself :)

Me too. I actually kept kreuz and traded gawn to him lol, meaning I'll have to bench one of cox, kreuzer and minson when kreuz comes back. Good cover at least  :P

[nrich102]

Minson for this week.... Sandi for the rest of the season..

Sandi > Minson. IMO another 10 ppg average.

Do you really think Sandi will average like he used to? He has a high score of 80 so far this year, and I don't think he will do what he has done before. Having said that, his scores have just been getting better, so there is still room for improvement.

[pommyadam]

Minson for this week.... Sandi for the rest of the season..

Sandi > Minson. IMO another 10 ppg average.

Do you really think Sandi will average like he used to? He has a high score of 80 so far this year, and I don't think he will do what he has done before. Having said that, his scores have just been getting better, so there is still room for improvement.

do note that he had a 5 point Q4 in that 80 though, was otherwise on track for a ton
and because this did interest me (for quite a while, or since Nicholls went down)
Minson - Adelaide (Jacobs?), Lions (Leuenberger) and Dees (Spencer/Gawn/Whoever really, inflated scores)
Sandi - Dees (see Minson's), Port (Lobbe, not overly convinced about) and StKilda (McEvoy, but final day and StKilda with no motivation)

omitting the Dees game (same opponent) - and this week's games (considering one's already been played)
Jacobs and Leuey vs Lobbe and McEvoy
i think Lobbe and McEvoy will give up more points, hence Sandi

[jamfrank]

Hmmm 40 points. Very glad I went with mino.