Ask Q (2/8/13)

[Master Q]

As always ask me your questions and I'll give you my honest opinion!

Deadline: 6:30 EST  :)

[Jigsaw]

Swallow -> Jack or Scooter?

N. Reiwoldt or Bartel at F7?

Cheers.

[essendon2]

Is Titchell --> Beams worthwhile , or is Cotchin --> Beams better? (Both require a downgrade)


or....

JJK --> Bartel
&
Ibbotson --> Enright

Or

JJK --> Bartel
&
Leuenberger --> Krezuer

Or

Cotchin --> Jack
&
JJK --> Bartel

[LF]

Hey Q
Trying for overall whats the best move this week?
Have done Daw to Grundy already.
Looking at possibly bringing in Beams.
$300k in the bank.

Backs
Goddard,Heppell,Gibbs,Cannon,Heater,Terlich,Clisby,Wilson

Mids
Ablett,Swan,Pendles,Jelwood,Barlow,Stanton,Mundy,S.Mitchell,T.Mitchell,B.Kennedy

Rucks
Cox,Goldy,Nicholls,Grundy

Forwards
Johnson,Bartel,JJK,Lewis,Martin,Rocky,N.Roo,Staker

[Master Q]

Swallow -> Jack or Scooter?

N. Reiwoldt or Bartel at F7?

Cheers.

Jack

Roo

[Master Q]

Is Titchell --> Beams worthwhile , or is Cotchin --> Beams better? (Both require a downgrade)


or....

JJK --> Bartel
&
Ibbotson --> Enright

Or

JJK --> Bartel
&
Leuenberger --> Krezuer

Or

Cotchin --> Jack
&
JJK --> Bartel

Definitely Titch to Beams or JJK --> Bartel and Berger --> Krezuer

[Master Q]

Hey Q
Trying for overall whats the best move this week?
Have done Daw to Grundy already.
Looking at possibly bringing in Beams.
$300k in the bank.

Backs
Goddard,Heppell,Gibbs,Cannon,Heater,Terlich,Clisby,Wilson

Mids
Ablett,Swan,Pendles,Jelwood,Barlow,Stanton,Mundy,S.Mitchell,T.Mitchell,B.Kennedy

Rucks
Cox,Goldy,Nicholls,Grundy

Forwards
Johnson,Bartel,JJK,Lewis,Martin,Rocky,N.Roo,Staker

Get rid of Terlich, second option probably TMitchell to Beams.

[BGK]

Bench Grimes or Ibbo please Q?

[Lozza]

Who should I get in?

Henderson: Gives dpp with Staker and performing well, puts Ibbo to D7 and can swing forward if i need it.

Hansen: Cheap and apart from his 0 has been scoring well.

Lewis: The 'safe' option and should score well since he plays more in the mids.

Cheers Q

[LF]

Hey Q
Trying for overall whats the best move this week?
Have done Daw to Grundy already.
Looking at possibly bringing in Beams.
$300k in the bank.

Backs
Goddard,Heppell,Gibbs,Cannon,Heater,Terlich,Clisby,Wilson

Mids
Ablett,Swan,Pendles,Jelwood,Barlow,Stanton,Mundy,S.Mitchell,T.Mitchell,B.Kennedy

Rucks
Cox,Goldy,Nicholls,Grundy

Forwards
Johnson,Bartel,JJK,Lewis,Martin,Rocky,N.Roo,Staker

Get rid of Terlich, second option probably TMitchell to Beams.

I'm thinking of holding Terlich for bench cover then trading Clisby out next week after his price rise.

If I do Titch to Beams like I'm thinking in your opinion would you bench?

[MinistryOfFootball]

Swallow > Beams?

[LaHug]

Pick two:
1. Nicholls to Grundy

2. a) Dwyer to Beams
b) Dwyer to Jelwood
c) Dwyer to Barlow
d) Dwyer to other premo
e) Dwyer to basement priced rookie (unless you can tell me a better downgrade option)

3. a) Boyd to Beams
b) Boyd to Jelwood
c) Boyd to Barlow
d) Boyd to other premo
e) Boyd to basement priced rookie (unless you can tell me a better downgrade option)

4. a) Terlich to Ricky Henderson
b) Terlich to Hanley
c) Terlich to Enright
d) Terlich to other premo back (who?)

5. Something else that I missed because you're smarter than me...



Please and thank you :D

[Master Q]

Who should I get in?

Henderson: Gives dpp with Staker and performing well, puts Ibbo to D7 and can swing forward if i need it.

Hansen: Cheap and apart from his 0 has been scoring well.

Lewis: The 'safe' option and should score well since he plays more in the mids.

Cheers Q

Lewis if it means completing your forward line, if not Henderson.

[Master Q]

Hey Q
Trying for overall whats the best move this week?
Have done Daw to Grundy already.
Looking at possibly bringing in Beams.
$300k in the bank.

Backs
Goddard,Heppell,Gibbs,Cannon,Heater,Terlich,Clisby,Wilson

Mids
Ablett,Swan,Pendles,Jelwood,Barlow,Stanton,Mundy,S.Mitchell,T.Mitchell,B.Kennedy

Rucks
Cox,Goldy,Nicholls,Grundy

Forwards
Johnson,Bartel,JJK,Lewis,Martin,Rocky,N.Roo,Staker

Get rid of Terlich, second option probably TMitchell to Beams.

I'm thinking of holding Terlich for bench cover then trading Clisby out next week after his price rise.

If I do Titch to Beams like I'm thinking in your opinion would you bench?

Mundy or Stanton

Swallow > Beams?

Yep

[LF]

Hey Q
Trying for overall whats the best move this week?
Have done Daw to Grundy already.
Looking at possibly bringing in Beams.
$300k in the bank.

Backs
Goddard,Heppell,Gibbs,Cannon,Heater,Terlich,Clisby,Wilson

Mids
Ablett,Swan,Pendles,Jelwood,Barlow,Stanton,Mundy,S.Mitchell,T.Mitchell,B.Kennedy

Rucks
Cox,Goldy,Nicholls,Grundy

Forwards
Johnson,Bartel,JJK,Lewis,Martin,Rocky,N.Roo,Staker

Get rid of Terlich, second option probably TMitchell to Beams.

I'm thinking of holding Terlich for bench cover then trading Clisby out next week after his price rise.

If I do Titch to Beams like I'm thinking in your opinion would you bench?

Mundy or Stanton

Cheers for your help and your opinion Q :)