Season defining decision, Kruez v Goldy v Minson?

Started by Baggers2012, August 02, 2013, 03:24:14 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which ruckman

Kruezer
10 (34.5%)
Goldstein
10 (34.5%)
Minson
9 (31%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Baggers2012

Hey guys, who do you reckon to complete my rucks? Cheers

seejaay


Baggers2012



Blues Blues Blues

Welcome to my dilemma mate. I think I have finally settled on Goldy

Swoozie

I'd go Goldstein, but don't think you can go wrong with any of the three.

Baggers2012

Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on August 02, 2013, 05:14:03 PM
Welcome to my dilemma mate. I think I have finally settled on Goldy

Jt finished reading through your thread! I've actually decided against Goldy, all the top sides in my main league have Goldy, one side has Minson, nobody Kruezer. I'm keen to bring in a finals POD so im now tossing up between Kruez & Minson.
Minson plays the dees on grand final w/e so he could finish big. Though Kruez has the ability to go big against jt about anyone. The 35k difference has me jt leaning towards Minson, but i cant help but feel Kruez will be a bit fresher for the run home. Been the lone ruckman jt about all season is surely taking it's toll on both Minson & Goldy.

The extra 35k could be handy for my last 3 trades though!

Vinny

Kreuzer for me ! Will be looking to prove his talent as Blues gun for September.

Blues Blues Blues

Quote from: vinny on August 02, 2013, 05:28:18 PM
Kreuzer for me ! Will be looking to prove his talent as Blues gun for September.

Are you trading him in mate, or is this just your vote? I can't make my f*#king mind up, it's like I'm waiting for one light bulb moment or stand out fact/statistic that will make it easy for me but it is not forthcoming!  :(

roo boys!

Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on August 02, 2013, 06:05:54 PM
Quote from: vinny on August 02, 2013, 05:28:18 PM
Kreuzer for me ! Will be looking to prove his talent as Blues gun for September.

Are you trading him in mate, or is this just your vote? I can't make my f*#king mind up, it's like I'm waiting for one light bulb moment or stand out fact/statistic that will make it easy for me but it is not forthcoming!  :(
Sorry, I tried :P

Guess I've made my stance pretty well known, but honestly don't think this decision will make or break you as there will most likely be 5 ppg max between them

I'd still go Goldy > Kruez > Minson

But as I said, that's probably about 118, 117 and 116.9 average in the run home :P

Blues Blues Blues

Quote from: roo boys! on August 02, 2013, 06:08:57 PM
Quote from: Blues Blues Blues on August 02, 2013, 06:05:54 PM
Quote from: vinny on August 02, 2013, 05:28:18 PM
Kreuzer for me ! Will be looking to prove his talent as Blues gun for September.

Are you trading him in mate, or is this just your vote? I can't make my f*#king mind up, it's like I'm waiting for one light bulb moment or stand out fact/statistic that will make it easy for me but it is not forthcoming!  :(
Sorry, I tried :P

Guess I've made my stance pretty well known, but honestly don't think this decision will make or break you as there will most likely be 5 ppg max between them

I'd still go Goldy > Kruez > Minson

But as I said, that's probably about 118, 117 and 116.9 average in the run home :P

Haha, you helped mate and I am almost over the line with Goldy, the price difference a big factor plus consistency. Whilst Kruz in great form, as a Carlton supporter I know how frustrating he can be!

HotTiges

Not sure how Kreuzer will go against Sandi to be truthful..

Blues Blues Blues

Quote from: HotTiges on August 02, 2013, 06:14:42 PM
Not sure how Kreuzer will go against Sandi to be truthful..

Lucky I don't need to win this week, just want a ruckman to go nuts in the finals

n185

I went Kruezer, his  last 5 games average is too good not to get, bit worried with Goldstein playing Adelaide away , While Carlton have WB i still expect Kruezer to deliver the goods next week!

roo boys!

#14
Quote from: n185 on August 02, 2013, 06:25:37 PM
bit worried with Goldstein playing Adelaide away ,

Yeah, Adelaide are on fire this year.

Oh wait

At least their ruckman Sam Jacobs has been a dominant force all season long

Oh wait

But at least he'll get good support from McKernan (doubt he'll play this week and next still up in the clouds) and Tippet

Oh wait


Goldyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy