Ruckin hell... what to do? Roll up roll up... who wants cheers!!

Started by pikla, July 30, 2013, 04:10:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

bonebones

Godly will get rested. By his own admission he is exhausted. Has laboured all the work this year and must get a rest. I'd go Minson.
Although if I were in your position I would sell NicNat, throw Cox into ruck and get Walker or Rioli. That way you still have roughy as your DPP and you can use Rowe as your loophole to decide which of cox, Nichols or Maric score you want to take.

HotTiges

Quote from: bonebones on July 30, 2013, 11:02:39 PM
Godly will get rested. By his own admission he is exhausted. Has laboured all the work this year and must get a rest. I'd go Minson.
Although if I were in your position I would sell NicNat, throw Cox into ruck and get Walker or Rioli. That way you still have roughy as your DPP and you can use Rowe as your loophole to decide which of cox, Nichols or Maric score you want to take.

I'm not sure he will get rested or managed.. I reckon Daw or Currie if fit will come in and share ruck duties.. Those 2 aren't capable if rucking the whole game as a sole ruckman I would of thought..

pikla

Quote from: HotTiges on July 30, 2013, 11:38:08 PM
Quote from: bonebones on July 30, 2013, 11:02:39 PM
Godly will get rested. By his own admission he is exhausted. Has laboured all the work this year and must get a rest. I'd go Minson.
Although if I were in your position I would sell NicNat, throw Cox into ruck and get Walker or Rioli. That way you still have roughy as your DPP and you can use Rowe as your loophole to decide which of cox, Nichols or Maric score you want to take.

I'm not sure he will get rested or managed.. I reckon Daw or Currie if fit will come in and share ruck duties.. Those 2 aren't capable if rucking the whole game as a sole ruckman I would of thought..

If North are no chance at finals surely there's no need to continue busting Goldy's balls. Makes sense to give some opportunity to Currie/Daw. Even if sharing duties this will surely effect his scores

Ricochet

Quote from: pikla on July 31, 2013, 08:46:34 AM
Quote from: HotTiges on July 30, 2013, 11:38:08 PM
Quote from: bonebones on July 30, 2013, 11:02:39 PM
Godly will get rested. By his own admission he is exhausted. Has laboured all the work this year and must get a rest. I'd go Minson.
Although if I were in your position I would sell NicNat, throw Cox into ruck and get Walker or Rioli. That way you still have roughy as your DPP and you can use Rowe as your loophole to decide which of cox, Nichols or Maric score you want to take.

I'm not sure he will get rested or managed.. I reckon Daw or Currie if fit will come in and share ruck duties.. Those 2 aren't capable if rucking the whole game as a sole ruckman I would of thought..

If North are no chance at finals surely there's no need to continue busting Goldy's balls. Makes sense to give some opportunity to Currie/Daw. Even if sharing duties this will surely effect his scores
Yeh at some point if North definitely can't can't make finals I can see Currie/Daw coming into the side

Sabretooth Tigers

 :)
Thinking IMO that Goldy, Minson and Kreuzer are the only real choices at the moment. Could Nth Melb have shown their "rucking" intentions by playing Daw up forward ?? Maybe Goldy rucks alone but if he needs a spell the for/ruck type player fills the void. Can see Curry wearing different colours next season, wouldn't mind them being black with a golden sash.
;)

Swoozie

Goldy in for mine, started the year with him and he has been a shining light.
I'd say take the risk of him getting rested because he's miles ahead of anybody else.

Blues Blues Blues

Quote from: Swoozie on July 31, 2013, 10:48:09 PM
Goldy in for mine, started the year with him and he has been a shining light.
I'd say take the risk of him getting rested because he's miles ahead of anybody else.

F*#k! I had made my mind up on Minson, and now you have brought some doubt back in. If it wasn't for risk of being rested I'd take Goldy. I guess I have Nicholls as back up if he did get rested?!  :-\

dmac07

Agree, go goldy. My second choice would be Walker as Carlton will be looking to come home strong for that 8th/9th spot for finals and wont be resting any start players.