Trade Swallow or not?

[pinochio]

Have had the swallow rollarcoaster for ages now...if he wasnt playing the dees it would be easier lol

but he is playing dees and got that 160 on them last year...


do i trade him or ride him out...if i trade id get cotch :)



help

[m_zulian]

You would be killing yourself if he goes bang!

[Alka]

Cotch? Against Sydney and a likely tag? I wouldn't risk it.

Back the guy playing the team that will get demolished.

[pinochio]

pretty definitive keep :)

thx guys was leaning to keeping as well

[powersuperkents]

I've got him as well man  :-\ I know he's a pain in the ass but I'd rather generate cash than waste it  ;)

[powersuperkents]

Grimes on field, Swallow on field. I'm playing 3rd team in my league I'm second.. we are both on 48 points but I'm smashing him in %. You may think my team is finished but he has Nicholls :) & Green Vest Elliott :) (If I lost to a team with Jamie Elliott that would be it).

Haha Swallow-> Beams next week is a lock for me Pinochio ;) Jump on as well. Beams is the only mid besides Swan, Gaj, Pendles & arguably Barlow who I rate highly this season. The rest are all inconsistent screw ups and you just have to pick one and hope for the best :) Beams is a certain 110+ this season and that is better than anything else out there

[Kellogscrunchynut]

Traded Swallow for Griffen before the lockout :).

[m_zulian]

At least with trading out swallow now I don't have to ride the roller coaster. Same scenario when birch all got injured

[powersuperkents]

At least with trading out swallow now I don't have to ride the roller coaster. Same scenario when birch all got injured

+1

Same here man, I prefer injuries rather than just chopping a player because that way you don't have to watch in anguish when the player you dumped tonnes up :) Lucky Swallow got injured because I didn't want to chop him without a reason and solves my Titchell v. Swallow dilemma   

[Dave085]

Im not sure what to do. I hope he doesn't play next week coz its between him and Gray for M9. Grays DPP is very handy though...

[ShaynoB]

Im not sure what to do. I hope he doesn't play next week coz its between him and Gray for M9. Grays DPP is very handy though...

He's out for around 12 months so u won't have an issue in trying to decide who to play

[Dave085]

Im not sure what to do. I hope he doesn't play next week coz its between him and Gray for M9. Grays DPP is very handy though...

He's out for around 12 months so u won't have an issue in trying to decide who to play

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/sport/afl/andrew-swallow-badly-injured-in-kangaroos-romp/story-fnca0u4y-1226686839128

[shaker]

You would be killing yourself if he goes bang!

He didn't go bang but his tendon did  :'(