Good/which trades? Opinions please

Started by jmoynihan9, July 26, 2013, 06:34:57 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

jmoynihan9

Originally this week was trading Hartlett to Hanley and Wines to Barlow but with Hanley and Goodes(in my mids) out I have instead done a double mid upgrade to 'finish' (albeit Hartlett starting) my side. These trades were Goodes and Wines to Cotchin and Jelwood, sending Titch to M9.
My defence and midfield as it stands after the trades looks like this:
DEF: Goddard, Heppel, Gibbs, Ibbotson, Hanley, Hartlett. (Clisby(E), Frost)
MID: Ablett, Swan, Pendlebury, O'Keefe, Jack, Stanton, Jelwood, Cotchin (Titch(E), Hunter)

Originally the team looked like this before any trades:
DEF: Goddard, Heppel, Gibbs, Ibbotson, Hartlett, Grimes (Clisby(E), Frost)
MID: Ablett, Swan, Pendlebury, O'Keefe, Jack, Stanton, Titch, Goodes (Wines(E), Hunter)
RUC: Roughead, Kreuzer (Nicolls(E), McBean)
FOR: Johnson, Cox, Martin, Rockliff, Stokes, Kennedy (Staker(E), Bartel)
Cash: $219,500

What do people think would be better, the trades i have done at the moment or upgrading to Barlow, fielding Titch and then trading Goodes to a premo Defender, and if so which one.

What are peoples thoughts, will cheer!

m_zulian

Personally, I have traded Barlow in my side this week. Your midfield must include Barlow with his run home and going for his tenth ton in a row this week. Field Titchell this week and trade in Mckenzie for Goodes. GC have a good run home

Spinking

Cotchin's price is good but hasn't set the world on fire this year, I agree with MZ you should consider Barlow instead.

jmoynihan9

What if next week after downgrading stake and bartel returning i could trade one of my underperforming premos into Barlow?
Better to get him this week or next?

m_zulian

Quote from: jmoynihan9 on July 26, 2013, 07:11:10 PM
What if next week after downgrading stake and bartel returning i could trade one of my underperforming premos into Barlow?
Better to get him this week or next?
Has b/e of over 130. up to you.
Personally, I wanted to improve my side this week so have traded him in despite his high b/e