Scooter v Boyd

[smoothM24]

Picking up one of these two boys this week and cant decide. Boyd is a proven gun but scooter is playing well this year. both coming off injury but im not to worried about that. Who does every think will scorer more from now on until years end ?? Alot of the West Coast mids out dont no if this helps or hinders scooter.

[fertalong]

I would go scooter because he is on the up whereas boyd is winding down even though he's proven.
Realistically both should score similar anyway.

[Capper]

Why are you only choosing between these 2 players, surely there are more players out there

[Adamant]

I would go scooter because he is on the up whereas boyd is winding down even though he's proven.
Realistically both should score similar anyway.

Winding down? his last four scores before injury were 144, 112, 152 and 90. :P

I'd go Boydy for sure, bringing him back in next week myself.

[LaHug]

I'd back Boyd over Scooter by a mile. Hell, I'm even considering Boyd over Barlow right now (probably won't do it though).

[Mr Micah]

I think you should go Boyd. He has been a great performer over the years.

[nrich102]

I think you should go Boyd. He has been a great performer over the years.

+1. Boyd has consistently performed over many years.

[hardnut]

I'd go Scooter this week as there should have been no problem with him retaining his fitness base with a broken thumb. Boyd I think was soft-tissue so might need a week or 2 to get going after a stop-start season. tbh I'd go Masten/Jelwood this week as there BE is quite low and look at one of these two after some more exposed form. I certainly wouldn't get Boyd this week though

[Ricochet]

Jump on Boyd mate. He's proven and with Griffen in such good form, Boyd won't cop much attention

[disco1992]

Jump on Boyd mate. He's proven and with Griffen in such good form, Boyd won't cop much attention

Boyd never gets attention any way because his disposals don't effect games too much as he is quite ineffective, dt wise always a great pick.

Hope he starts struggling now with 2014 close and get him price below 100 ave

[Holz]

Boyd over everyone but Swan and Ablett, even than he is the better value of the 3.