Scott Thompson v T.Mitchell

Started by Hagebear, July 25, 2013, 01:40:43 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who to field?

Scott Thompson v FREMANTLE
3 (21.4%)
Tom Mitchell v RICHMOND
11 (78.6%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Hagebear

Pretty self explanatory who to field. Thommo v Freo. Looking tired and with Danger out is probably to get the Crowley tag, or Tom Mitchell v the Tigers. Will be alot of outside ball for him to win. Thoughts?

bigdaddyg

Thompson isnt the player of years past but will never get the vest, mitchell hasnt had it yet and it is always a possibility.  Is a hard one, if i had to chose i'd field Mitchell, fingers crossed though

nrich102

Quote from: bigdaddyg on July 25, 2013, 01:55:00 AM
Thompson isnt the player of years past but will never get the vest, mitchell hasnt had it yet and it is always a possibility.  Is a hard one, if i had to chose i'd field Mitchell, fingers crossed though
Mitchell hasn't had the vest WTF? He did in his first game.

Adamant

This is a tough one. Usually I'd say Thompson in a heartbeat, but he will get the Crowley tag and doesn't handle it too well at all...

I'd go Titch.

yorgis

Thompson got the red vest last week !!  Has sore groins and is a chance he may not play this week

Ricochet

Quote from: yorgis on July 25, 2013, 10:20:29 AM
Thompson got the red vest last week !!  Has sore groins and is a chance he may not play this week
And then add the Crowley tag = field TMitch imo

Mailman the 2nd

Quote from: nrich102 on July 25, 2013, 06:04:18 AM
Quote from: bigdaddyg on July 25, 2013, 01:55:00 AM
Thompson isnt the player of years past but will never get the vest, mitchell hasnt had it yet and it is always a possibility.  Is a hard one, if i had to chose i'd field Mitchell, fingers crossed though
Mitchell hasn't had the vest WTF? He did in his first game.

He was a late inclusion so he had a green vest. Obviously not knowing completely how good he was then, he won't get the vest unless he's injured

Moona

With ROK potentially out of the midfield, Titch should get more of a go in there as well, so I'd back him in over Thommo to get the bigger numbers.

m_zulian

Using formula from the following link http://dreamteamtalk.com/2013/07/23/tbettas-bullets-round-17-2/
Mitchell has a projected score of 87.9 and Thompson has a projected score of 87.7. It's a close one but Mitchell just. Thompson has lowest score in last 5 games and Mitchell has the highest score in last 5 games.

Jukes

Closely related, do you guys reckon I should play Jaeger (vs Carlton) or TMitch (vs Richmond)?

tbagrocks

Here I will call it, although clearly Sando still gunning for the 8, Thommo won't get up! :o

Either way he has a groin issue, wether or not Griggy comes in late, Thommo is a rick for starting!