Who is the better option for Hanley....

Started by Mark, July 24, 2013, 08:16:11 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who is the better option for Hanley....

Ibbo
5 (22.7%)
Gibbs
4 (18.2%)
Cannon
7 (31.8%)
Heppell
4 (18.2%)
Malceski
2 (9.1%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Mark

Please help by a vote and comment why ??

GoLions

Either Ibbo or the Cannon, but I'd wait a week first. Gives you time to see how long Hanley should be out for, and also Ibbo is going to drop in cash a bit you would think. If you have to trade this week, then probably Ibbotson.

_wato

Yeah if you are in that much trouble and you need to trade Hanley by all means do it, but I don't think getting rid of him is the best idea if you don't have to do it. He'll be back in 2-3 weeks to finish off the year.

If you have plenty of trades and cash go for it, but if not hold. Trades are too precious.

I'd go for the Cannon if you we're to trade.. Best option IMO.

Vinny

The Cannon.

I've been talking him up alot haha but I think he is seriously the best option mate. :P

FonFatty

Quote from: vinny on July 24, 2013, 09:30:02 PM
The Cannon.

I've been talking him up alot haha but I think he is seriously the best option mate. :P
He is a popular defender now, however I think he can be trumped scoring wise for the remainder of they year @ Gold Coast.
No and I don't mean Harbrow or Broughton.

The forgotten man, Danny Stanley....
Having a look at their draw for finals especially I think Stanley is very good value @ $372k and IMHO I think he can see out a 105 average for the remainder of the year. Guy has the knack to find the ball.
Averaging 20 possessions a game @ 77% efficiency, gets a lot of contested ball, just think he can finish the season of on a high.

When you compare the 2 it is interesting;

McKenzie ave:
21 disposals
5 cont possessions 13 uncont possession
77% efficiency
6 marks
3 tackles

Stanley ave:
20 disposals
8 cont possessions 12 uncont possessions
77% efficiency
5 marks
3 tackles
Now looking at those numbers the only thing separating the 2 is their price tag $90k differential.
If anything Stanley gets more contested ball and also Stanley has been a bit down this season thus far, he has improvement left in him. McKenzie you can say has broken out this year.
Last year Stanley finished 3rd in the clubs B&F playing only 13 games.
After rnd 8 he played in all but one match for the suns and ranked 3rd behind Ablett and Bennell in disposals, effective kicks, contested possessions, hard ball gets, loose ball gets, uncontested possessions and handball receives.
I just think he is worth the risk, IMO he can not do any worse, currently ave 75 and I think he can get that to 85-90 by seasons end. In order to do that he has to average 105-110 from now and like I said I believe he can with the draw that the suns have coming up. Also only in 0.28% of teams, would be the best unique defender you can get. Especially for those teams in the top 100 looking for someone different.
Food for thought!!!

Mark


Ramus