Which Trade? (Picture)

[Adamant]

Option 1: Goodes --> Murphy and Robinson --> Cloke/FWD under $435,500.

Option 2: Goodes --> Murphy and Hanley --> Enright/Any DEF.

Option 3: Robinson --> Cloke and Hanley --> Hibberd
                OR
                Robinson --> Lewis and Hanley --> DEF under $403,000.



I'm leaning towards Option 1 as it allows me to get rid of some dead weight in Goodes' and Robbo has pissed me off all year. Murphy is an absolute bargain and will go up about 20k with ton. Only negative is that I'll have to field Scotland until Hanley is back, and he's in shocking form. I could trade Hanley next week if Scotland gets under 70 again though...

[its me lads]

I also like option 1 however Robbo could get a call up this week, no guarantee that he'll actually do any good though. Cloke should be good for the rest of the year, I might get him this week.

[Adamant]

BUMP.

Really stuck here. I've changed my options slightly though...








Option 1: Goodes --> Lewis (via Robbo DPP) and Hanley --> Enright.
Pros: Don't have to worry about fielding Robinson (spud and could be the sub) or Scotland (spud without the sub risk).
Cons: Have to pass up on Murphy, which is annoying as I think he is outstanding value at his price. But I'll probably be bringing in Boyd/Beams next week anyway, which means Murph would be on the bench if I did get him this week (although I'd be majorly pissed if he goes 110+ and Boyd/Beams spud up, meaning I'd want him over them anyway next week, but I'd be paying around 25k more...).

Option 2: Goodes --> Murphy and Robbo --> Cloke.
Pros: Allows me to upgrade Robbo to a gun who could go bang this week, and Murph is a steal at his price.
Cons: There probably won't be much difference between Murph and Titchell in scoring (ie waste of having one of them bench). Have to field Scotland which could be very risky considering he scored 47 last week. Hanley could be back in two weeks though.

Option 3: Goodes --> Murphy and Hanley --> Enright.
Pros: Don't have to field Scotland. Enright is a gun and Murph at his price = win.
Cons: Have to field Robbo and he could potentially start as the sub. Hanley could be back in two weeks which might seem like a waste trading him to Enright (avoids fielding spud Scotland though).



Option 1 will probably net me the most points as it effectively means I field Enright + Lewis over Scotland + Robinson. Although I have to miss out on Murph. It's a shame I can't afford Cloke over Lewis, otherwise I'd probably lock this in...

The difference between option 2 and 3 is basically Scotland + Cloke vs Enright + Robinson. Can't split the two. :-\

Thoughts? cheers.

[its me lads]

I vote for option 1  ;D  (they are all option 1)

I like the sound of "Goodes --> Lewis (via Robbo DPP) and Hanley --> Enright."

Seems to me to have the best pro's and the con of missing out on Murphy isn't too bad. Sure he is great value but IMO Beams will do better for the rest of the year.

[Adamant]

I vote for option 1  ;D  (they are all option 1)

I like the sound of "Goodes --> Lewis (via Robbo DPP) and Hanley --> Enright."

Seems to me to have the best pro's and the con of missing out on Murphy isn't too bad. Sure he is great value but IMO Beams will do better for the rest of the year.

Haha, I just copy and pasted all three options, forgot to change the option number - fixed. ;)

Thanks mate, option 1 looks the best on paper for sure. Leaning towards that I think.

Alternatively, I could go Cloke and Trent McKenzie/sub 410k defender over Lewis/Enright as well.

[its me lads]

I vote for option 1  ;D  (they are all option 1)

I like the sound of "Goodes --> Lewis (via Robbo DPP) and Hanley --> Enright."

Seems to me to have the best pro's and the con of missing out on Murphy isn't too bad. Sure he is great value but IMO Beams will do better for the rest of the year.

Haha, I just copy and pasted all three options, forgot to change the option number - fixed. ;)

Thanks mate, option 1 looks the best on paper for sure. Leaning towards that I think.

Alternatively, I could go Cloke and Trent McKenzie/sub 410k defender over Lewis/Enright as well.

No worries. I'm a fan of The cannon, brought him in a few weeks and I really like the McKenzie and Cloke option over Lewis/Enright