Who to trade out to reclaim Johnson next week?

[powersuperkents]

Please help, this is a must do trade after lockout to bring Stevie J back into my side and give me a fantastic forward line with my Buddy-> Nroo trade over two weeks :)

Forward line next week:
Stevie J, Nroo, Bartel, Dusty, Stokes, Rockliff, Lee, Staker/Random rookie

[Brenny G]

Please help, this is a must do trade after lockout to bring Stevie J back into my side and give me a fantastic forward line with my Buddy-> Nroo trade over two weeks :)

Forward line next week:
Stevie J, Nroo, Bartel, Dusty, Stokes, Rockliff, Lee, Staker/Random rookie

Tough one perhaps Hrovat? but I'm keeping him for now, I wouldn't get rid of staker, cemented his spot in the lions best 22 and is playing some pretty good footy, but yeah it's a tough one I kept stevie J this week and put staker on the field :)

[BT]

I don't think Hrovat's cash generation can be trusted. His red vest today proved he is prone to a low score, and take out the 99 and he really hasn't been too impressive.

Personally I'm scratching him for grigg or curren, depending on who looks better, in two weeks time. Wouldn't be a huge loss to get rid of Hrovat this week.

[powersuperkents]

I'm sort of siding with Swallow-> Murphs and Buddy-> Stevie J now. I think Murph will provide almost the same output as Swallow and Stevie J will only extend my weekly scores :)

thoughts?

[caluuum]

I'm sort of siding with Swallow-> Murphs and Buddy-> Franklin now. I think Murph will provide almost the same output as Swallow and Stevie J will only extend my weekly scores :)

thoughts?

I think changing Buddy>Franklin is a bit of a waste of a trade tbh hehe

but yes Murph and SJ will outscore them easy!

[powersuperkents]

I'm sort of siding with Swallow-> Murphs and Buddy-> Franklin now. I think Murph will provide almost the same output as Swallow and Stevie J will only extend my weekly scores :)

thoughts?

I think changing Buddy>Franklin is a bit of a waste of a trade tbh hehe

but yes Murph and SJ will outscore them easy!

haha sorry about that  :P I'll edit that right away encase it confuses anyone else  ;)

But do you agree that is the best possible option? :) I think Murphy will probably outscore Swallow for the remainder of this season. I checked out Swallow's scores last year and he is a completely different player. He has gone down in both consistency and ceiling. Instead of straight 90's he churns out 70's & 80's and he used to go 150-165. Now he goes 141 in r1 and that's it  :-\

[browny_wce]

I held him!
Will be doing a final midfield upgrade next week  8)

[caluuum]

I'm sort of siding with Swallow-> Murphs and Buddy-> Franklin now. I think Murph will provide almost the same output as Swallow and Stevie J will only extend my weekly scores :)

thoughts?

I think changing Buddy>Franklin is a bit of a waste of a trade tbh hehe

but yes Murph and SJ will outscore them easy!

haha sorry about that  :P I'll edit that right away encase it confuses anyone else  ;)

But do you agree that is the best possible option? :) I think Murphy will probably outscore Swallow for the remainder of this season. I checked out Swallow's scores last year and he is a completely different player. He has gone down in both consistency and ceiling. Instead of straight 90's he churns out 70's & 80's and he used to go 150-165. Now he goes 141 in r1 and that's it  :-\

Yeah not really sure what's wrong with him. I think players like Ziebell, wells, Adams, Cunnington have taken a bit more of the workload off him?

However in saying that Murphy hasn't really been setting the world on fire either... 8 round average of around 70

[powersuperkents]

I'm sort of siding with Swallow-> Murphs and Buddy-> Franklin now. I think Murph will provide almost the same output as Swallow and Stevie J will only extend my weekly scores :)

thoughts?

I think changing Buddy>Franklin is a bit of a waste of a trade tbh hehe

but yes Murph and SJ will outscore them easy!

haha sorry about that  :P I'll edit that right away encase it confuses anyone else  ;)

But do you agree that is the best possible option? :) I think Murphy will probably outscore Swallow for the remainder of this season. I checked out Swallow's scores last year and he is a completely different player. He has gone down in both consistency and ceiling. Instead of straight 90's he churns out 70's & 80's and he used to go 150-165. Now he goes 141 in r1 and that's it  :-\

Yeah not really sure what's wrong with him. I think players like Ziebell, wells, Adams, Cunnington have taken a bit more of the workload off him?

However in saying that Murphy hasn't really been setting the world on fire either... 8 round average of around 70

Yeah I know  :-\ The soul purpose of the trade is just to provide me with $100k to get Stevie J back. I think that is the most urgent thing and trading Swallow isn't too big a price to pay in my books :) Could do a straight Swallow-> Stevie J trade and keep Buddy as liquidated capital on my forward bench and I'll eventually upgrade him to another premium mid and sub Stevie J into the forwards :) How does that option sound?

[powersuperkents]

Hrovat-> Adam Carter is the best option in my opinion now :)

[caluuum]

After Hrovats score it will take him a few more weeks to rise than what he would have normally have been.
Hrovat down to Carter and then buddy>sj

Too easy

[powersuperkents]

After Hrovats score it will take him a few more weeks to rise than what he would have normally have been.
Hrovat down to Carter and then buddy>sj

Too easy

haha and I already have Hutchings as more than adequate cover and I'm aiming for Hutchings in M10 & T Mitch in M9 so too easy. Adam Carter be able to gain enough for a late upgrade before finals ;D and most importantly Stevie J is back ;) and if Swallow starts going big he's in my side so no regrets from good performances (can't say the same about bad ones  :P )