Start Nicholls or McEvoy

[littleblueboy2906]

Simple McEvoy v Port (Lobbe)

or

Nicholls v Collingwood (Hudson)

[MC]

I'm in the same boat - I chose Nicholls + Minson as starters. McEvoy on the pine. Good luck!

[Colliwobblers]

i started nichols over maric in DT

i have cox and nicnat in SC and am STILL tempted to start nichols over one of those eagles - especially against sydney....

big call i would start mcevoy against port ?

witts is going ok and he is playing for the pies too so nichols has two to beat, and if the pies are on there may not be much ball going nichols way - not sure...

[MC]

Not a bad call, but Hudson is not that quick around the ground, so i'd back Nicholls to have the edge in that aspect. Confirmed for me when Dixon wasn't named.

McEvoy: 8/14 have been 100+ (59 - 140 is his range) **53 when subbed off against Melb not included**
Nicholls: 2/6 have been 100+ (76 - 139 is his range)

Seems like McEvoy is more chance to hit the 100, but has a greater danger of going sub 60.