Which trade? Will cheer!

Started by jmoynihan9, July 19, 2013, 04:59:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which Option

1
3 (100%)
2
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 0

jmoynihan9

Option 1:
Dwyer to Grimes via Staker
Blicavs to McBean(allows for Cox to be used as bench cover for both Rucks and Forwards wherever needed)

Option 2:
Wines to Barlow
Blicavs to McBean

CURRENT TEAM:
DEF: Goddard, Heppel, Gibbs, Ibbotson, Hartlett, Staker. Int: Clisby(E), Frost
MID: Ablett, Swan, Pendlebury, Jack, O'Keefe, Stanton, Wines, T.Mitchell. Int: Goodes(E), Hunter
RUC: Roughead, Kruezer. Int: Nicholls(E), Blicavs
FOR: Rockliff, Kennedy, Martin, Stokes, Bartel, Cox. Int: S.Johnson, S.Dwyer(E)
Cash: $66,000.

What everyones opinions? Want to keep T. Mitchell as long as possible so if I do the mid upgrade will virtually finish my mids for a while but trading in Grimes will strengthen a relatively weak defence.

Will cheer!

Ricochet

How much cash do you have mate?
Really think you need to upgrade Wines and Grimes is a steal at that price

jmoynihan9

Edited it in have 66k on the dot mate.
And yeah hes been my M9 for a while but last weeks trades sent Stevie J forward and Wines onto the field.
Originally was upgrading Wines but Grimes just seemed so cheap like you said!

Ricochet

Bugger. Ok yeh grab Grimes this week mate and upgrade Wines next week i reckon.

chief007

Barlow has a high BE 135 ish and wines 85ish it all depends if u reckon grimes is worth getting on if u said at the start of the year he was the price he is now everyone would have him, the deez are going better now so he should be able to get good scores for rest of year, Barlow seen to crack the ton every week and won't go up ur down too much -8k this week with his BE so if u wana take a bit of a risk with grimes grab him and get Barlow next week or go with mr consistent and get Grimes next week, can always go heartless to grimes next week, hope that's of help to ya good luck

jmoynihan9

#5
Cheers for the help fellas gonna run with the Grimes trade,
Now its just a matter of who to field.
Two out of Wines, Goodes and Hartlett whats your opinions?

Ricochet

Quote from: jmoynihan9 on July 19, 2013, 05:45:45 PM
Cheers for the help fellas gonna run with the Grimes trade,
Now its just a matter of who to field.
Two out of Wines, Goodes and Hartlett whats your opinions?
Probably Goodes and Hartlett i reckon mate.
Goodes has been solid most of the year and seems to score better against the stronger sides (Freo 82, Pies 81, Bombers 97, Adelaide 115, Port 86)
Wines has been a bit quiet lately with only 2x 76+ scores since round 4 (112 against Pies and 90 against Essendon),

thanme

I agree with the Grimes trade. Barlow will cost around the same, if not a little less next week whereas Grimes will start to jump (assuming his form remains).

As for fielding, I'd pick Goodes of the 3.

Artax

I think 1 mate.. I have brought in Grimes this week as I think he is a bargain at that price. Have him in elite, very happy.

Think Wines to Barlow next week is a lock too.