Need some expert advice please !

[Vinny]

Hey fellas ! This is my team-

D- Goddard Gibbs Mckenzie Hanley Goodes Wilson.    Clisby Docherty.
M- Gaz Swan JPK Jack Selwood Cotchin TMitchell Hrovat.    Colq Kmart.
R- NicNat Goldy.    Nicholls Witts.
F- StevieJ Rocky Zorko Cox JJK  Franklin.   Daniher and Garner.

16k and 6 trades.

In Rd 19 and 20-

Nicholls > Moller
Witts > McBean

Colq / KMart > Pendles
Wilson > Duffield

Leaves with me with 2 trades.

I am aware I've got two donuts this week and my team isn't very good :P But my run home is super easy now and my spot in finals is guaranteed.

Does this plan look good ? I'll chuck you a cheer for any advice :)

[HotTiges]

Good work pal.did i read somewhere this is your first year? Anyways next year you will improve for sure and not get stuck with rookies and donuts in ya final side..anyways next week I'd look for a cash injection.via Nicholls perhaps? Little bit early but ya need cash.dont want to be relying on the likes of Wilson hrovat at this time of year with no cash. Good luck pal.love ya comments this year but most of all I love your Joel Garner pick! Big Bird!

[Vinny]

Thanks a lot mate ! Yeah it is my first year :P Your advice has been great too.

Yeah I might just wait for the cash cows for a few weeks. Hahaha I have no idea why Garner is in my side.

Thanks again - I gave you a cheer :)

[roo boys!]

Plan does look good, but with the doubts hanging over NicNat's head and injuries I'd almost be more inclined to trade him and play Nicholls as R2...would make you more cash and possibly (haven't checked the cash) allow you to just go:

NicNat > McBean

Colq/KMart/Hrovat if you can't afford the other two > Pendles
Wilson/Clisby if you can't afford Wilson > Duffy

Which would be pretty much the exact same team but with Witts as possible ruck coverage (you'd have McBean's DPP anyway to bring in Cox), Nicholls instead of NicNat which is the better option at the moment and an extra trade.

For some reason I feel 2 trades is running very low, 3 is do-able.

[Vinny]

Thanks RB !

I was thinking about that - NicNat is driving me crazy and will leak more cash.

I think I will start a poll to see what people think. NicNat as R2 or Nicholls.

Gave you a cheer :)

[roo boys!]

No worries mate, as I said, I feel NicNat is just a bit too risky, most likely going to trade him to Roughy myself but it's a tough one to pull the trigger on knowing what he's capable of.

Nicholls should be more than serviceable as R2, the kid's a gun.

[Vinny]

Haha yeah ! Looks like you've convinced me. :P Thanks mate.

[tor01doc]

Hey, you've got McKenzie!!

There is something that makes me uncomfortable about condoning the trading out if a player who is selected to play, whilst you have donuts headed your way.

If NicNat is selected then I would hold. Especially if the guy coming in isn't getting a game.

Would you consider dumping Spuddy, moving NicNat forward and grabbing MrBean for cash and DPP?

Just a different option for you.

[Vinny]

Sure do ! His got a good finals draw. ;)

Haha that's interesting but I think NicNat will continue to struggle mate.

Going to trade him out.. I think :-[

Gave you a cheer - Thanks Doc !