Jake Carlisle

[Purplehaze25]

Is anyone considering this guy? 3 round Average of 107, 5 round of 92
has a relatively good draw
Playing up forward occasionally
Nice POD?

Thoughts?

[Vinny]

I don't think so man ! Too risky at this stage of the year.

You want proven players and at 420k - I think an extra 100k is worth it. Knowing your more likely to get good scores consistently.

Thats just IMO :)

[fever]

nope

[Purplehaze25]

What about Hartlett? worth the risk?
Trying to work in a defender for Vlas, but working around getting in Griff for Rampe
only have $452,300 to spend

[Vinny]

What about Hartlett? worth the risk?
Trying to work in a defender for Vlas, but working around getting in Griff for Rampe
only have $452,300 to spend

Hartlett - I think he is worth the punt ! He is playing in the midfield getting more of the ball. He is averaging 89 of the last five.

He has been consistent in that 75-95 mark. If you bring him in - I think that's what you will get.

Up to you if you think its worth the punt in your situation :) Plus Port are travelling nicely and have confidence.

[specky92]

Carlisle pretty much has to win essendon the game to get over 100. Look elsewhere.

For around the same price here are some alternatives

Hamish Hartlett (as mentioned) $427,700 Last 4 rounds average:88.5

Pearce Hanley $415,200 Last 4 rounds average: 67 (we know what he's capable of, could wait a week with a high BE)

Danyle Pearce $414,000 Last 4 rounds average: 92 (Same final 4 as Stanley but different order)

Danny Stanley $414,000 Last 4 rounds average: 87.5 (Has a very nice finals run, Melbourne, Port, Saints, Giants)

Jack Hombsch $411,900 Last 4 rounds average: 95

[ronl]

I think Jake will be another Dustin Fletcher, great player but don't go near him in SC.

[specky92]

I think Jake will be another Dustin Fletcher, great player but don't go near him in SC.

Fletch averaged over 100 for 3 consecutive years...