Which H defender?

[quinny88]

HELP

[specky92]

I voted for Heppell, has only dropped below 86 twice with a low of 73, seems to have settled into his new role nicely and is now delivering consistent 90-110 scores, Also has a lower BE than Hibberd. Jump on!

[Dayze]

I reckon HIbberd over heppell just.
Houli the smokey.
Few of us have some tough decisions to make on this one. Nobody is screaming pick me in the backline.
Mite sit on Birchall for a week and things mite b a bit clearer

[nrich102]

I think Heppell

[TeeJay]

I got Houli a few weeks back and he's been a great pod. They are all good options tho

[Jackross10]

Heppel for me

Heppel, Hibberd, Houli

[Jroo]

Heppell always finds a lot of the ball, so I see him as the safest option.

[Ringo]

Heppell for me. Hibberd has shown some signs of slowing over the last 2 weeks. Houli may be a POD for you but you know more about him than I do.

[quinny88]

Thanks for the input guys.
Leaning towards Heppell at this stage but still a bit up in the air

[Escapist]

If you don't have Ibbotson I'd take him over all of them. Otherwise Heppell.
Wouldn't touch Hibberd at the moment- seems to be slowing (I hope i'm wrong) and Houli only consider if the rest of your team looks like it's been pulled out of "Coach Crawf" or "Pimp my Side".

[quinny88]

If you don't have Ibbotson I'd take him over all of them. Otherwise Heppell.
Wouldn't touch Hibberd at the moment- seems to be slowing (I hope i'm wrong) and Houli only consider if the rest of your team looks like it's been pulled out of "Coach Crawf" or "Pimp my Side".

I just cant trust Ibbotson. He is scoring well but I wonder if it is just a hot patch as its only been over 8 rounds.
Haha whats wrong with Houli? he's averaging 96 over the season and 101 over the past 5 rounds

[Big Mac]

If you don't have Ibbotson I'd take him over all of them. Otherwise Heppell.
Wouldn't touch Hibberd at the moment- seems to be slowing (I hope i'm wrong) and Houli only consider if the rest of your team looks like it's been pulled out of "Coach Crawf" or "Pimp my Side".

I just cant trust Ibbotson. He is scoring well but I wonder if it is just a hot patch as its only been over 8 rounds.
Haha whats wrong with Houli? he's averaging 96 over the season and 101 over the past 5 rounds

I think he might be saying to only take Houli if you need a POD.

[The Mighty Hoops]

If you don't have Ibbotson I'd take him over all of them. Otherwise Heppell.

+1

[billnats]

I've gone Ibbo too but Heppell best of the one's you have listed.

I too cant trust Ibbo but I thought I will take a chance.

[bottlemart]

There's not much love for Hanley atm.  Homsche is an interesting one, very good average but haven'e seen enough of him so far this year, but he seemed to do well GWS last year, but with some risk in taking him over the others.

I'm leaning towards Hibbotson or HMckenzie.  Of the 3 you've thrown up, tough choice, maybe Houli if I had to choose from the 3.