Kieren Jack or Jobe Watson ?

[Vinny]

Which one and why ?    ???

[Jackross10]

I would add a poll ! Watson

[Jimmykidd]

Kieren is a good POD. Love him. Good consistent 100's every week. Only thing is his ceiling isn't very high..

[eaglesman]

jobe can score massively however he can be restricted in games and tagged imo

jack is unlikely to cop a tag and for a coach that has him the joy he brings u for tackling like crazy is just so joyful haha but he prob doesnt have the ceiling like jobe

flip the coin ... safer bet is jack though

[Mat0369]

Both if possible

[kfewster]

Jobe, much bigger ceiling then Jack in the box.

Jack will get you 110-120, but not 140-150 that Jobe will get you. Price around $540k (assuming he drops a little this week) is good value for Jobey.

If you have a good balance in your mids, go Jobey, if you have a few players that are up & down (aka Stevie J, Danger, Jelwood or Maybe Cotch) maybe go Jack.....up 2 you bud.

[_wato]

Both if possible

Haha yes! But it depends on your midfield I feel. You don't want too many of Watson, Dangerfield, JPK, and others in your team as they can have the stinker and if it all happens at once in the same round you're shot
I feel that Jack is as consistent as it gets, probably the next best to Ablett, Pendles and Griff at this stage. So really it's upto you. Watson might average an extra 5ppg but not as consistent, but still very consistent.

[_wato]

Jobe, much bigger ceiling then Jack in the box.

Jack will get you 110-120, but not 140-150 that Jobe will get you. Price around $540k (assuming he drops a little this week) is good value for Jobey.

If you have a good balance in your mids, go Jobey, if you have a few players that are up & down (aka Stevie J, Danger, Jelwood or Maybe Cotch) maybe go Jack.....up 2 you bud.

Didn't see this buddy, but exactly what I meant. Sorry mate.

[Vinny]

Haha thanks fellas ! Leaning towards Jack for consistency. Seems like the extra 20k will be worth it.

[kfewster]

LOL all good wato, great minds think alike.

Just wish someone would light a fire under Cotch, dragging my mids down atm.

[fever]

jobe fo sho

[Vinny]

Now I'm confused haha. The poll is leaning heavily towards Watson ! This is gonna be on my mind all week.