Help with last mid. Will cheer for advice!

Started by blackrose, June 20, 2013, 02:54:30 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which mid?

Joel Selwood
Kieren Jack
Trent Cotchin
Brett Deledio
Michael Barlow

blackrose

Already have Danger, Swan, Ablett, Pendles, Jobe, Griffen, JPK.

Don't care about price/bargains just want the best possible midfield. Leaning more towards Lids at this stage. Cotch looks injured/out of form, Selwood has been rested once in the last 3 rounds of the last 3 years/looks out of form, Kieren Jack's ceiling not very high but has good consistency, Barlows start of season scores not too flash, Lids seems to cop the tag more than Cotch. Or I could wait to see if Beams will come good? Edit: Do not want S. Mitchell, A. Swallow, Stanton, Fyfe, Priddis.

Thanks

GM

For me mate it comes down to Jack & Barlow.
Jack has a good draw coming up and Barlows run home is great.
Barlow can go huge and Jack is consistent so go with your gut here mate.

shorty3264

If your not bothered about price, I'd say Joel Selwood or Kieran Jack, I mean really they should all average 110-120 for the remainder of the year, they are all jets. But Selwood will bounce back and Jack's end to 2012 was sublime.

tor01doc

Killer mids already. Wow.

I'd favour Deledio or Selwood.

Can't really lose so go the cheaper one?

Are you other lines this good? If so, what are you going to do with the prize?

GM

Selwood imo will get a rest near finals like he normally does.

Nails

If you want the best the best isn't the value option that has had a poor season. No guarantee that they'll just turn it around as if by magic.

Therefore I think you have to go with the players who have shown something and continue to show it.

Jack or Barlow for mine. If you want the most points it'd have to be out of these two.

ubeaut

I'd go Jack or Barlow if they are in less teams (I think they are).
I have Barlow and Selwood.

blackrose

Quote from: tor01doc on June 20, 2013, 03:08:56 PM
Killer mids already. Wow.

I'd favour Deledio or Selwood.

Can't really lose so go the cheaper one?

Are you other lines this good? If so, what are you going to do with the prize?

Haha I'm not doing too well overall wise this season so I won't win any prize... just going for league. Yeah forwards are Rocky, Buddy, Cox, Nicnat, Bartel, Stevie J and Rucks are Maric, Goldy and Backs are Goddard, Gibbs, Hartlett, Duffield and I'm getting Birchall in this week and either Pearce Hanley or Shaw next week.

blackrose

And thanks all gave everyone a cheer but hasn't helped make up my mind yet everyone has differing opinions haha

tor01doc

Nice team though.

Interesting poll too.

Cheers.

ubeaut


fever

Quote from: greenmoon on June 20, 2013, 03:10:28 PM
Selwood imo will get a rest near finals like he normally does.

it's like you read my mind but beat me into threads

fever

barlow tends to pound weaker opposition.

_wato

Am I the only one who would pick Cotch? He's been playing poor footy such as Selwood, and he's still managing to average 110.
Richmond will be all guns blazing to make finals, so he'll play every game. Imagine if he hits hot form? Last year he averaged 120 in the second half of the year! They have a soft draw- GWS, Brisbane, WB, Gold Coast, Saints, NM, aswell as a few top sides, but he seems to play decent against good opposition. He's been spending a little bit more time across half forward- Imagine if he starts kicking goals like last year, only has two this year kicked 21 last year. Is priced at $532,000 is set to drop again so $515-520k and you have a bloke whos hit the ton 8 out of 10 games, and seems to get points just touching the footy.
If I was you he'd be the man  ::)

fever