Pearce Hanlry vs Heath Shaw

[mmurphy3]

Which DEFENDER?

[ubeaut]

Had Heater from the start and just got Hanley.I reckon both are musts in the backs.
Heater has a higher ceiling but Hanley is a gun playing midfiled. Can also go big. maybe choose the cheaper?

[hawkers65]

Shaw easily for me, don't know how Hanley or Voss for that matter will help him shake the tag where as Shaw isn't known to be shut down by a tagger and has also been in very good form. I'm strongly considering bringing in Oxley as F8 instead of Daniher just so i can afford Shaw rather than Hanley.

[Holz]

Shaw easily for me, don't know how Hanley or Voss for that matter will help him shake the tag where as Shaw isn't known to be shut down by a tagger and has also been in very good form. I'm strongly considering bringing in Oxley as F8 instead of Daniher just so i can afford Shaw rather than Hanley.

Im thinking this too, next year avoid all players from birsbane unless they are super cheap. No clue what he is doing but i suspect tanking, he always plays gun midfielders out of position.

Heath Shaw 80 130 125 98 97 146 136 thats 116 average in his last 7 games. No brainer (much like shaw ;) )

[mmurphy3]

Shaw easily for me, don't know how Hanley or Voss for that matter will help him shake the tag where as Shaw isn't known to be shut down by a tagger and has also been in very good form. I'm strongly considering bringing in Oxley as F8 instead of Daniher just so i can afford Shaw rather than Hanley.

i brought Oxley in as my F8 to mate :)

[fever]

yeah shaw, but ideally both imo.

[ubeaut]

Shaw easily for me, don't know how Hanley or Voss for that matter will help him shake the tag where as Shaw isn't known to be shut down by a tagger and has also been in very good form. I'm strongly considering bringing in Oxley as F8 instead of Daniher just so i can afford Shaw rather than Hanley.

Shaw CAN be shut down (Jordan Lewis usually does alright) but it rarely happens.

[fever]

hmmm i actually just looked at coll's draw. they have a horror SC finals run. syd haw wc nth.

this is actually making me second guess heater (who i'd considered a lock to be my final def coming into finals).

[nrich102]

Pearce Hanley, even with the Voss factor. Heath Shaw is Heath Shaw and will do something stupid or get "Injured"

[_wato]

Heaters already been injured so far, so one would say he's had his 'absence' from the team and will be raring to play every game from here on on. Having said that yes he does have a very bad finals run, but his next 5 weeks is brilliant.
PA, Carlton, Adelaide, Gold Coast and GWS.
But also saying that Hanley has a very soft draw after round Round 14, and that's when ill be jumping on and when he would be at his lowest. Hanley just mate.

[Vicious Sandwhich Attack]

I voted heater for you, looks like scoring well, but he is on my never again list.

Good luck with him if you go down that path  ;)