Heath Scotland to??

[kenjo]

At this stage I have decided I don't want to invest any money in Scotland for an 'upgrade' so its either sideways or downgrade, and with no cheap downgrade options I have pretty much narrowed it down to Brett Goodes or Grant Birchall?

Does anyone have any advice to help me out, cheers :-)

[bigdaddyg]

I'd go Birchall, he should come good soon.  Hawks have Brisbane, Port and Bulldogs in next 4 weeks should get back to form

[glynman]

Birchall should outscore Goodes for the rest of the season. I wouldn't bother with Goodes. Anyone who has him (like me) is either planning to make him a final upgrade or use him as good bench cover.

He'll probably turn into Gibbs for me next week unless I can afford Terlich --> Gibbs.

[Windigo]

I'd keep Scotland. At least until Birchall shows some kind of form.

[pommyadam]

I'd go Birchall, he should come good soon.  Hawks have Brisbane, Port and Bulldogs in next 4 weeks should get back to form

did you say that he was going to score well vs GWS and the Dees
he's a DEF, so should score well against the better teams (when the ball is down that end more)

i'd hold off for a while at least