Are You Trading Out Cotchin?

Started by Windigo, June 17, 2013, 01:10:36 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Are You?

This Week
2 (6.5%)
Next Week (If He Goes Under The Ton Again)
5 (16.1%)
Unsure
8 (25.8%)
Backing Him In (Nope)
16 (51.6%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Windigo

Cotchin has been shizen this year, wondering how many are trading him out. I'm thinking if he scores sub par again he is gone for Barlow or Boyd next week...

its me lads

Holding him for now. He' a star and should bounce back. I've still got O'Meara (undecided) along with Macaffer, Dwyer, Crouch who will all go before him. If I trade those out first then he's still underperforming then I'll get rid of him, he will be cheap by that stage but it is what it is.

Glort

With 2 trades every week and lots of rookies around, he's going to become bench warmer no.1 :)

fertalong

I started with him and his first 3 games looked very good. I'm so glad i was forced to trade him since him and stanton were both injured and not playing the same week. I was forced to trade one and picked cotchin.

If I still had him I would trade him out after the byes for a performing premo. He just hasn't had his usual influence and seems to be spending a lot of time forward rather than in the guts.

rider

Quote from: Glort on June 17, 2013, 01:54:49 PM
With 2 trades every week and lots of rookies around, he's going to become bench warmer no.1 :)
+1 i don't have him but once he bottoms out im thinking the same thing luxury trades permiting...

muntedmyke

If hrovat is in my downgrading cotchin to Mitchell. Yolo  :P

Chelskiman

Holding for now but only because I want to fix other areas first, in particular my backline.  I'll complete my forwards this week, jump on Gibbs next week and then I'll decide.  I only need one more to complete my mids, so I may keep him and if all goes well I can trade in a 9th premium mid and keep Cotch as back up.  He is a gun, and we do have a fairly soft draw for the rest of the season.  He got two good tons against the Dogs and Saints earlier in the year, so you gotta back him for at least.

Kellogscrunchynut

Holding for now although he'll be on the chopping block if he continues to perform pooly, and with a war chest of $528k any cash lost shouldn't be a problem.

Footy God


powersuperkents

I think I'll trade him out this week. He's finished, I don't think he'll break a 95 average this season and I honestly don't recommend him to anyone. Even at his price.. Would have you got Rockliff last year? Useless shower player I can't believe I started with him and he's repaid me is sh*t and only two actual premium level scores. There are rookies who are better than him  :-\ Out of my pure hate and shear rage for him I'm going to oust him for Barlow or Jack and save money instead of Hutchings-> Cornes (I feel a lot safer with either Barlow/Jack rather than Kane tbh, I really want him but now that I can get him I'm feeling unsure (for me it is a big investment) I am considering Cotchin-> Cornes though  ;)

Flame

I traded his sorry butt out weeks ago- I'm sick of these so called premos spudding it up!!

henry

I started him, traded him out then got him back last week as an underpriced premo. I'll look like even more of an idiot if I trade him out now lol, holding probably for the rest of the season, even if he needs to be at M9  ::)

Jigsaw

I'll probably be holding for now, although it will depend on how Tom Mitchell goes this week. I currently have Mitchell at M9, but if he's solid then I might consider trading out Cotchin, so I can start him (GWS & Demons in the coming weeks).

Whilst he has had one price rise thus far, I'm considering downgrading Cotchin to K-Mart next week. That way, I can make some cash off it, still have decent cover (Should keep his spot for awhile still) and bring in another premo in a few weeks time.

Just a thought at this stage, but a tempting one at that.

tbagrocks

I resisted yesterday but this thread makes me laugh ;D

powersuperkents

I'm now holding out of necessity  >:(

I think we all have bigger problems in our team to worry about this round  :-\

@Tbagrocks: Didn't you trade Dangerfield to Libby at the beginning of the season ;) haha