What to do with Caff?!?!

[pinochio]

Was planning to trade him out this week in preparation for rd 13, idea was to get as many rd13s out as possible....
....with 293k in the bank the plan was to go berger > minson and caff > barlow

but then caff goes and smashes out back to back tonnes and i feel a tad silly trading him out....


my other rd13 bait is laird/bennedy who must go this round or next since i have 5 rd13 mids and 3 in defence....
...while i also have terlich and evans as bait but they play next week hence i cant really afford to trade them

is it a bad play trading out caff, we cannot expect him to tonne up right - he is not a keeper, right ? :S


thoughts :)

[powersuperkents]

Bennedy still has a very low BE whilst Caf's is -10. I think hold those two for another week to help confirm your decision

[Windigo]

JOM->Barlow

He has to go at some point...

[pommyadam]

you have a rd13 FWD problem?!
who do you have there?

i'm keeping, the likes of Jaeger (and Evans/Neade/Stevenson) need to be shown the door first

[powersuperkents]

I dumped O'Meara last week for Stants  :-\ I still think it was a good trade in prospective terms but so far it hasn't turned out too good. I agree though dump O'Meara he has no more cash to generate

[pinochio]

JOM->Barlow

He has to go at some point...

he already has ;)

...in preperation for rd13 lol


anyone ii trade out from rd13 has a low breakeven (caff/laird) but my rd12 boys in evans and terlich are the ones 'i should' be trading, but then im stuck with too many rd13s out lol

get my dilemma guys :)

[powersuperkents]

JOM->Barlow

He has to go at some point...

he already has ;)

...in preperation for rd13 lol


anyone ii trade out from rd13 has a low breakeven (caff/laird) but my rd12 boys in evans and terlich are the ones 'i should' be trading, but then im stuck with too many rd13s out lol

get my dilemma guys :)

what is your current team?

Could go Evans -> Hrovat

[pinochio]

ive got hrovat as well PSK :)

god, gibbs, hepD, laird, thurlow, terlich (vlas, goodes)
swan, gaj, swallow, jelwood, stants, watto, evans, pendles (hrovat, bennedy)
cox, blicavs (berger, naismith)
rocky, bartel, SJ, JJK, dusty, caff (staker, buddy)
293k

team without any trades...

atm thinking and the ones i planned are caff/berger > minson/barlow

[powersuperkents]

ive got hrovat as well PSK :)

god, gibbs, hepD, laird, thurlow, terlich (vlas, goodes)
swan, gaj, swallow, jelwood, stants, watto, evans, pendles (hrovat, bennedy)
cox, blicavs (berger, naismith)
rocky, bartel, SJ, JJK, dusty, caff (staker, buddy)
293k

team without any trades...

atm thinking and the ones i planned are caff/berger > minson/barlow

Tough I think you should have dropped Evans a while ago  :-\

I don't think you should trade Caf out yet but Berger-> Minson looks quite good :) 

These are the second trade players I'd consider in your position:
JJK-> Premium for has already had their bye or with a r13 bye (this provides a full forward line but I think you should wait for Nroo)
Evans-> T Mitch (a week early) or any other rookie (preferably not r13 makes it tough you already have Hrovat)
Naismith (don't know who he is)/Blicavs(if your game)-> Nicholls

[pinochio]

ha naismith is just a 89k blank for me :)

ye man, evans has sucked big time. but he is playing in rd13, which is only positive lolz!


i could go berger > nicholls and evans up to barlow but i end up +1 on rd13 guys...

[powersuperkents]

ha naismith is just a 89k blank for me :)

ye man, evans has sucked big time. but he is playing in rd13, which is only positive lolz!


i could go berger > nicholls and evans up to barlow but i end up +1 on rd13 guys...

I think that is the best option mate :) You free up cash get the GCFC starting ruck and another premium mid to add to the pot ;)

[pommyadam]

i could go berger > nicholls and evans up to barlow but i end up +1 on rd13 guys...

your rucks are unaffected by rd13, it's those pesky mids that are the problem
remember it's the best 18 of those you can actually put on the field, not just the best 18

[pinochio]

ha naismith is just a 89k blank for me :)

ye man, evans has sucked big time. but he is playing in rd13, which is only positive lolz!


i could go berger > nicholls and evans up to barlow but i end up +1 on rd13 guys...

I think that is the best option mate :) You free up cash get the GCFC starting ruck and another premium mid to add to the pot ;)

better yet i think berger/jjk > minson/barlow is even better since like you said ill have 7 forwards playing in rd13 so i can afford to have bennedy/caff on the bench...

i miss out on nicholls...oh well :/

[powersuperkents]

ha naismith is just a 89k blank for me :)

ye man, evans has sucked big time. but he is playing in rd13, which is only positive lolz!


i could go berger > nicholls and evans up to barlow but i end up +1 on rd13 guys...

I think that is the best option mate :) You free up cash get the GCFC starting ruck and another premium mid to add to the pot ;)

better yet i think berger/jjk > minson/barlow is even better since like you said ill have 7 forwards playing in rd13 so i can afford to have bennedy/caff on the bench...

i miss out on nicholls...oh well :/

How do you go JJK-> Barlow. I've heard people mentioning these sorts of trades before and I still don't get it  ??? hhaha can someone please explain it to me? Is there something I don't know?  :)

[pinochio]

ha naismith is just a 89k blank for me :)

ye man, evans has sucked big time. but he is playing in rd13, which is only positive lolz!


i could go berger > nicholls and evans up to barlow but i end up +1 on rd13 guys...

I think that is the best option mate :) You free up cash get the GCFC starting ruck and another premium mid to add to the pot ;)

better yet i think berger/jjk > minson/barlow is even better since like you said ill have 7 forwards playing in rd13 so i can afford to have bennedy/caff on the bench...

i miss out on nicholls...oh well :/

How do you go JJK-> Barlow. I've heard people mentioning these sorts of trades before and I still don't get it  ??? hhaha can someone please explain it to me? Is there something I don't know?  :)

had bennedy was in in mids...so i DPP move him down to forwards...in effect trade jjk for a mid...

get it :)