Hrovat or Mitchell this week?

Started by pinochio, June 05, 2013, 07:39:27 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

?

Hrovat
17 (51.5%)
Mitchell
16 (48.5%)

Total Members Voted: 2

pinochio

Getting 1 of them early this week, doing a double upgrade next week with my 300k :D.

Have like 19/20 players playing so getting Hrovat isnt bad at all for me, just depends on who is more important in the long run.



Is Hrovats JS enough to make him a slight favorite over Mitchells obvious scoring potential. 

thx

fertalong

Hrovat is playing next week and will gain cash earlier than mitchell.
You can still do double upgrade next week and pick up mitchell in r13, so definitely hrovat this week.

pinochio

Quote from: fertalong on June 05, 2013, 07:41:23 PM
Hrovat is playing next week and will gain cash earlier than mitchell.
You can still do double upgrade next week and pick up mitchell in r13, so definitely hrovat this week.

done a bit of planning and right now since ill have to get rid of caff/kennedy and laird by rd 13 I may not be able to get mitchell in rd 13....mayyybe rd 14 at a higher price....

thats my dilemma :P

get it?

ADEZ

Quote from: pinochio on June 05, 2013, 07:48:47 PM
Quote from: fertalong on June 05, 2013, 07:41:23 PM
Hrovat is playing next week and will gain cash earlier than mitchell.
You can still do double upgrade next week and pick up mitchell in r13, so definitely hrovat this week.

done a bit of planning and right now since ill have to get rid of caff/kennedy and laird by rd 13 I may not be able to get mitchell in rd 13....mayyybe rd 14 at a higher price....

thats my dilemma :P

get it?

I have a similar one, post round 12 I will have a midfield of:

Ablett, Swan, Stanton, Watson, Pendlebury, Jack, Priddis, Cotchin      (Hrovat, Martin/Mitchell)

I can't decide between Martin and Mitchell, both can score, both have shaky JS and sub risk, I think Martin could be the better rookie, but Mitchell is better for the byes

eaglesman

Quote from: ADEZ on June 05, 2013, 10:03:34 PM
Quote from: pinochio on June 05, 2013, 07:48:47 PM
Quote from: fertalong on June 05, 2013, 07:41:23 PM
Hrovat is playing next week and will gain cash earlier than mitchell.
You can still do double upgrade next week and pick up mitchell in r13, so definitely hrovat this week.

done a bit of planning and right now since ill have to get rid of caff/kennedy and laird by rd 13 I may not be able to get mitchell in rd 13....mayyybe rd 14 at a higher price....

thats my dilemma :P

get it?

I have a similar one, post round 12 I will have a midfield of:

Ablett, Swan, Stanton, Watson, Pendlebury, Jack, Priddis, Cotchin      (Hrovat, Martin/Mitchell)

I can't decide between Martin and Mitchell, both can score, both have shaky JS and sub risk, I think Martin could be the better rookie, but Mitchell is better for the byes

mitchell is the better option in my opinion

pinochio

hmm so you guys reckon I should get mitchell in this week even if it means forgoing the chance of getting hrovat next week???

its just mitchel JS scares me :/

ShaynoB

I don't reckon Mitchell will leave the team now.

I reckon Martin and Mitchell will score more but I think Hrovat is a must have

Martin this week, Hrovat next and then Mitchell week after

pinochio

Quote from: ShaynoB on June 06, 2013, 12:16:20 AM
I don't reckon Mitchell will leave the team now.

I reckon Martin and Mitchell will score more but I think Hrovat is a must have

Martin this week, Hrovat next and then Mitchell week after

next week im doing a double upgrade...so ill miss out on hrovat if i dont get him this week...

think ill go hrovat this week, his first game was just as impressive as mitchells (well almost :) )

dtvillage

Quote from: fertalong on June 05, 2013, 07:41:23 PM
Hrovat is playing next week and will gain cash earlier than mitchell.
You can still do double upgrade next week and pick up mitchell in r13, so definitely hrovat this week.

or you can pick up Mitchell now and take his score into consideration for your best 18...

considering he came on 13 mins into the second and racked up 98 you'd have to be sure that his score will count if he avoids the vest

Alka

Depends on how many mids you have playing. I've realised getting in Mitchell forces Evans to the bench. For that reason I'm getting Hrovat this week as it also gives me more flexibility with trades next week.

pinochio

Quote from: Alka on June 06, 2013, 04:27:11 AM
Depends on how many mids you have playing. I've realised getting in Mitchell forces Evans to the bench. For that reason I'm getting Hrovat this week as it also gives me more flexibility with trades next week.

eaxctly if i dont get hrovat this week then i must get him next week, but i wanna do a double upgrade.

hrovat it is :)

Toga


bigdaddyg

Marty Mattner has announced his retirement, maybe Mitchell's JS has gone up now

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-06-06/mattner-succumbs-to-hip

Artax

Backlin is pretty decimated at Sydney, probably won't affect the midfielders much but may see someone like Lockyer get a chance if fit