New to SC- any criticism/ help/ comments/ suggestions on my team would be great!

[dellanator]

Hi All

Any feedback/ suggestions/ criticiscm would be greatly appreciated- still kinda new at supercoach. Ive done a bit of research, but please give me any insight you can!

thanks a lot!!

BACKS:
B Goddard,
C Enright,
L Hodge,
C Brown (Hawks and him have to be better than last year don’t they??)
T Kennelly (I think it’s a decent price seeing as he retuning to AFL?)
N Malceski
L Greenwood
EMG: M Macguire, A Silvagni

MIDS
G Abblet
B Gibbs
J Watson
S Hill
C Masten (has dominated for preseason- for what that’s worth- and put on 4kg of muscle and killed it in the fitness tests etc)
A Walker
EMG: A Morabito, L Jetta

FORWARDS
M Pavlich (will be better this year and they’ll be playing him forward a lot more)
B Harvey
J Waite
S O’hailpin (both him, waite  and yarren should by rights get a bit more of it now Fevs gone??)
B Hall
J Ziebell
C Yarren
EMG: T Rockliff, S Grumbleton

[boxfactory]

is there really a c in maguire?

[hawk_88]

Pretty good team. Brown is an interesting pick and have considered him myself. He had a pretty bad year, and has show some of his old form in the preseason and things are looking up. Good pick!

Kennelly may be well priced (and a very popular choice) but he was never a prolific fantasy scorer. He will go up in price, but I'm not sure it will be to the extent that everyone is expecting.

Not sure about O’Hailpin either. Yes Fev is gone, but the 3 defenders that were on him are now free to move to other players. Those other players might struggle now when before they had relative freedom. (I have mentioned this before but good players don't detract but aid other players both in footy and fantasy).

Hall, Waite and Gumbleton are all risks. Don't dump them, but follow their form and re-evaluate before round 1. Too much risk for the forward line. Also, 3 carlton forwards is too unbalanced, especially considered what I mentioned above.


I do think that you could place some more rookies on this list. At least 2 on field, 1 forward and 1 mid. Replace Walker and Yarram with rookies, and use the cash to upgrade others. I would look at upgrading Harvey (I personally think injuries + age mean he is on the downward path) and Watson (a little more money can give you some very good players, not that Watson isn't a good choice).