Nic Nat vs SJ?

[doogz]

Rougly same price, same BE, same bye.

Who will score most by end of year? 

My current fwd line is: Cox, bartel, Martin, JJK, Franklin, Caff (neade, kennedy)

[James_Pies]

Depends how serious SJ's injury is but i'd probably go with Nic Nat.

[TheMoops]

I think ideally you want both in your team by end of year. Stevie J has an amazing run up to and around his bye and Geelong's run home around SC finals is also very good they play a lot of games at Skilled where he loves to score big.

However, this week NicNat has GWS. He won't be any cheaper than this probably til well after his bye, and I think this is the week to jump on as otherwise you'll fall well behind the rest of the SC world who will get him this week.

I'm getting both this week I think, obviously if you can do the same then do it but if not I'd go NicNat this week and SJ asap after that

[ts_its_me]

I'd wait til after their bye to pick them up.

And if you're only going to pick one i'd go for SJ because POD. everyone will be on Nic Nat

[TheMoops]

I'd wait til after their bye to pick them up.

And if you're only going to pick one i'd go for SJ because POD. everyone will be on Nic Nat

SJ a POD??  ::) I wish

[ts_its_me]

I'd wait til after their bye to pick them up.

And if you're only going to pick one i'd go for SJ because POD. everyone will be on Nic Nat

SJ a POD??  ::) I wish

Fair enough. No one in my league has him and everyone is talking up getting Nic Nat which is my I'm going SJ. Sorry I assumed this was the general case.

[TheMoops]

I'd wait til after their bye to pick them up.

And if you're only going to pick one i'd go for SJ because POD. everyone will be on Nic Nat

SJ a POD??  ::) I wish

Fair enough. No one in my league has him and everyone is talking up getting Nic Nat which is my I'm going SJ. Sorry I assumed this was the general case.

that sounds pretty good to me hahah get stevie j and smash everyone!   ;)

[Colliwobblers]

SJ won't be a POD for long, probalby already isn't

nicnat is beloved by SC - a must IMO

but both would look good in your fwd line no?

[Gigantor]

Wait til the teams are out. If big Cox is rested Nic Nat could be capable of scoring any thing! Could you imagine old man Brogan and spud Giles trying to keep up haha

[doogz]

Wait til the teams are out. If big Cox is rested Nic Nat could be capable of scoring any thing! Could you imagine old man Brogan and spud Giles trying to keep up haha

WIll get nic nat in for neade this weel and trade JJK (who has topped out) to SJ next week.

[Vinny]

I could go either too and am leaning towards Stevie J. Except for me Jobe Watson is also an option !

[doogz]

I could go either too and am leaning towards Stevie J. Except for me Jobe Watson is also an option !

Cant get in jobe.  Have soooo many rd13 bye players.  Playin caff is costing me 50ppg, so I must upgrade neade.