Hartlett out, or downgrade option

Started by Swoozie, May 14, 2013, 06:08:05 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Swoozie

Already going Wines to Priddis this week.
Should I give Hartlett the boot for someone like Hanley or Birchall?
Or instead should I downgrade for a rookie on the bubble and keep the faith with Hartlett?

GoLions

Entirely up to you. If you expect more of this from HH, trade him to Hanley this week. If you think this is the worst of it and he'll be much better for the rest of the year, then hold. Really struggling with the tag though, and opposition teams know it.

dwink23

I've done Wines to Priddis and Hartlett to Hanley this week - got him in for Gibbs and all he did was lose me $40k and a trade  ::) He's set to drop another $40k this week with a massive BE of 218, so I'd get rid of him if you can  ;)

fever


Redbaron

What will hart let's next 2 scores be Carlton and Geelong , if carazzo carves him up he could go into free fall , what do you think80&100??

HotTiges

Quote from: Redbaron on May 14, 2013, 09:42:47 PM
What will hart let's next 2 scores be Carlton and Geelong , if carazzo carves him up he could go into free fall , what do you think80&100??

that's if Carrazzo is fit to play? the guy can't even drive his car lol.. I'm going to have to back him, been a frustrating trade and fortunetly he didn't cost me any league games.. surely he can't have 3 bad games in a row

Redbaron

So hot tigers what scores are you predicting?

jfitty

Quote from: HotTiges on May 14, 2013, 09:58:35 PM
Quote from: Redbaron on May 14, 2013, 09:42:47 PM
What will hart let's next 2 scores be Carlton and Geelong , if carazzo carves him up he could go into free fall , what do you think80&100??

that's if Carrazzo is fit to play? the guy can't even drive his car lol.. I'm going to have to back him, been a frustrating trade and fortunetly he didn't cost me any league games.. surely he can't have 3 bad games in a row

I think you did similar trades to me HotTiges, Duffield out for Birchall and upgrade to Hartlett? Yippee...

Think we have to keep the faith in Hartlett. The kid is a gun, and I'm positive he can bounce back. He plays a ton of midfield, and is probably the best player in the Port team.

HotTiges

Quote from: Redbaron on May 14, 2013, 10:03:24 PM
So hot tigers what scores are you predicting?

geez it's chook lotto with HH. Reckon he will respond because I'm sure there would be a fair bit of critisim towards him and his teammates.. apart from Boak he is their best player so hopefully he gets a chop out.. even if he plays 1 out in the goal square or off half back or something.. seems to get stuck in the same spot in the mids..

scores? 70+ vs Carlton ill get back to you on the Geelong score next week!

Hazza09

If you have adequate trades remaining and cash then id ditch him.

Its obvious when he gets a tag he goes to water  >:(
Scary thing is he hasnt even been tagged by a recognised tagger yet...

Holz

thing is birchall will be 30k less next week and JPK is 60k more this week.

Both of those moves are worth a trade.