Hamish Hartlett

Started by Adamant, May 11, 2013, 04:33:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Will you be trading him?

Yep, he's gone.
24 (39.3%)
No, will still be a top 6 defender.
13 (21.3%)
Mabye, depends on other carnage.
24 (39.3%)

Total Members Voted: 4

Adamant

Brought him in two weeks ago for Gibbs and he has returned me scores of 32 & 37. He'll already drop about 40k, but he is gone for me regardless. For a 'premium' to have 3 scores in the 30s is disgraceful. Good riddance! >:(

Mr.Craig

I brought him in the week before...to replace the suspended Hanley. :(

At least I got a ton out of him. TBH I might just hold him, got other trades I'd rather do.

nrich102

He's gone. Ive had it with him.

Windigo

Had him from the start.

I'm thinking of booting...

henry

I started with him, so at least I got to have his 3 tons in a row. I don't understand why his worst is so bad, if he was scoring 50s and 60s I'd be ok with it but scoring 3 30s is just bizzarre and pathetic. I will be holding him for now though. I would be far more annoyed if I only just traded him in, so I understand your anger

pinochio

birch should be cherry ripe...with his 150 out of the cycle...

get birch in for HH b4 hawks soft run??

nostradamus

l traded Gibbs to Hamish Heartless when Gibbs tweaked his hammy

......will be traded out this week and on my blacklist forevermore

essendon2

this flowering cow.

flowering absolute cow.

powersuperkents

haha so happy :) When the carnage happened I choose Heppell doughnut and Stevie J over Franklin and Hartlett (I made more points through Stevie J alone that week than I would have made from both Buddy and Hartlett (significant amount more 60ish). I think dump him though

I'm dumping my two remaining Port players (Heath & Stevenson). I'm downgrading one and upgrading the other with the $240k+ that I'll have left from this week plus the downgrade :). Hopefully Birchall can score a 135-160 so I'll want to pick him :) so happy I picked Hanley as well ;D

powersuperkents

The problem for all you is Birch will still cost a significant amount to upgrade to even after this round. A lot of people with financial difficulties and other agendas (Wines, Stevenson & Heath) should consider doing a sideways Hartlett -> Heath Shaw trade. If I were in your position that would be the path I'd most likely take. He too is a yo-yo but at least his scores are either 60's or 100's whilst Hartlett's are 30's or 110's. See how he goes this week first :) I might try to bring him in for Stevenson or Heath if Birchall hasn't dropped enough   

its me lads

Not happy Jan, also traded him in just in time for his 30's. Might hold and get rid of cows first.

Senior

Got him in 2 weeks ago for Gibbs so copped his 32 and 37 :-\ I'll probably keep him this week so I can upgrade wines.

Kellogscrunchynut

Traded him for Goodes, might look at Hanley or a downgrade.

powersuperkents

Quote from: Kellogscrunchynut on May 11, 2013, 05:46:15 PM
Traded him for Goodes, might look at Hanley or a downgrade.
You could downgrade him to Goodes and pocket some cash ;) plus Goodes still has a negative BE

glynman

Will probably hold. Stevenson/Heath and Wines need to go first...I have way too many Port players