Priddis or A Swallow

[shuester]

I want to keep whichever one I get in for the season so who do you guys think will be better?

[the captain]

Get Priddis next week, breakeven over 170 and should be $450k.

[GoLions]

I think that excluding Priddis' concussed game, Swallow will avg around 5ppg more. However, I would still say get Priddis. You'll be getting him dirt cheap, and he should average around 110ppg, maybe just under. If you have him at M8 at the end of the season, you have done very well.

[shuester]

Problem is I have to get either in this round because I will be coping 2-3 donuts if I don't. So It has to be this round unfortunately

[jumbo]

what is your team?

we may be able to offer suggestions. Like can you downgrade something to get Vlastuin this week in your midfield to avoid a donut? (this will make you cash now and in the long run also..)

Wait on Priddis! and get him next week.

[shuester]

Goddard - H Shaw - Waters - Gibbs - Goodes - Vlaustin (Heath - Docherty)

Ablett - Pendles - Swan - Cotchin - Fyfe - Shuey - O'meara - Evans (Saunders - Dwyer)

Goldstein - Leuenberger (Daw - Blicavs)

Cox - JJK - Franklin - Zorko - Neade - Macaffer (Rowe - Daniher)

If you take out Gibbs, Goodes, Fyfe, Waters, Saunders, Cotchin and Docherty you get a horribly weak team so you get where Im going with I need to get either in this week. I cant even trade the ripe rookies like Dwyer and Heath :(

[bartyboys]

I'd be leaning towards priddis always comes good mid to late year

[Dayze]

Heath down to laird
Shuey up to jpk
Next week
Dwyer to lonergan
Evans maybe to priddis.
Haven't done the math but should b good.
Just a suggestions for the long term, one donut I think
Carnage in ur backline bud stay strong

[bottlemart]

Swallow this week, and Priddis next week if you can.

[Ricochet]

Yeh Swallow this week, Priddis still has a massive BE

[shuester]

Heath down to laird
Shuey up to jpk
Next week
Dwyer to lonergan
Evans maybe to priddis.
Haven't done the math but should b good.
Just a suggestions for the long term, one donut I think
Carnage in ur backline bud stay strong

cheers for the suggestion

[doogz]

Dont trade the shuey!  I am not.  Ridiculously easy run until the bye and hopefully last week shook us into form.  With kerr + Masto out you think shuey will have to step up a gear even with his calf problem of last week. 

THere is a possibility that he wont play with hams + flying over as emergencies.  Hope not with our outs but.

[Dayze]

I'm an eagles supporter and with Kerr out all the more reason why shuey will get tagged.
It's not a huge issue having shuey, it's just he is our second most damaging midfielder, and the second most likely to attract a tag...he will average exactly what he averaged last year.
Shuey is almost my favorite player. But I still wouldn't put him in my sc yet.
Other than priddis next week there is no west coast midfielder worth having this year mate

[doogz]

Crowley did f shuey over at the start of the year (53 i think).  He needs to learn to deal with a tag, if he cant, he wont be a true midfield gun.  I took the punt that he will learn to deal with the tag.

Who will tag him this week?  Raines is out isnt he?

[ubeaut]

Priddis may cop the hard tag.