heath or stevenson??

Started by Jimbo_11, May 09, 2013, 08:24:07 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

which one to trade??

heath
11 (50%)
stevenson
11 (50%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Jimbo_11

which one of these port rookies should make way for vlautuin in my team??

i know jeppa's juniors said to trade stevenson and hold heath, but heath's 50 odd breakeven worries me because i think he is more of a lockdown defender, whereas stevenson is the rebounding defender

opinions??????????

Affliction

Their scoring is similar. I traded heath based on break even

Zombie2.5

Tough one, whichever you end up choosing will probably be the wrong call :p

I think i would trade out Heath, he is more lockdown, especially with Trengove gone for a few weeks.

Although Port do like the ball with Stevo(great kick), his scoring has been concerning.
Heath has been more consistent, and Stevenson more inconsistent.

I still think trade Heath, he has made a little more money, and has a higher BE.
Don't think Trengove being out will help his scoring.

I would go Heath over Stevenson, just :/

slipknot_4

Quote from: Affliction on May 09, 2013, 08:34:36 PM
Their scoring is similar. I traded heath based on break even
+1

its me lads

Stevo was tagged a bit last week so he must rated as somewhat dangerous by the opposition, why Port were going to drop him a few weeks ago remains a concern.

More money to be made with Stevo as opposed to Heath, not much but probably enough to say trade out Heath.

nostradamus

l think it's a tough one really, in my opinion Stevenson has better scoring ability but Heath has better JS. So really l suppose it depends alot on what you're looking for

Jimbo_11

yeh heath is on his way out, stevenson will have more money to make


that being said, he will probs traded out next week for scotland anyway so not a big deal

Alka

Won't Stevo be making way for Pittard next week most likely?

I've kept Heath as he's more likely to actually keep getting games

Ricochet

Based on JS you have to get rid of Stevenson imo