Rookie defenders

[quinny88]

Which one should I get in? All things considered..

Price, JS, vest potential, scoring potential.. Who is the best option?

Know a bit about Vlastuin as a tigers supporter but have not heard or seen anything of Laird and Clarke?

[Noz]

Surely Clarke will be the first to go when Brisbane regain several of their talls.

Laird and Vlastiun seem to have the same JS so i don't think you could go wrong with either. I picked up Vlastiun last week and expecting big things from him in Cotchin's absence.

[Jroo]

I'd go with Vlastuin, reckon he's worth the extra $$$. The other don't seem to have great JS.

[newfreofan]

I'm hoping that Laird will be the emergency this week and either him or Docherty will play next week. Gone Vlas this week but need to offload Heath to someone next week.

[sammy123]

i will jump on colquhoin if hes not sub

[quinny88]

i will jump on colquhoin if hes not sub

before hes even played a game? Risky

[newfreofan]

Hella risky. Still, port rookies have done so well for us so far why should he be any different  :D

[sammy123]

yeah. Hw Looked good in nab. Playing well in seconds. Got to risk to win the biscuit hahahahhaahhaha. But hes going to be sub

[shorty3264]

i will jump on colquhoin if hes not sub

before hes even played a game? Risky

Yeh I've been thinking about it. Is the young tige worth the extra cash? Quinny? JROO? good tiger fans, would be interested in your thoughts.

[quinny88]

i will jump on colquhoin if hes not sub

before hes even played a game? Risky

Yeh I've been thinking about it. Is the young tige worth the extra cash? Quinny? JROO? good tiger fans, would be interested in your thoughts.

I cant answer as I know nothing about Clarke or Laird, hence the thread :P I do love Vlastuin though so leaning towards him at this stage.
Just want someone to pump up the others so I can justify saving a bit of cash.

2 weeks ago I saved cash by getting Evans instead of Mayes and thats turned out just fine so far

[roo boys!]

Not considering Sierakowski? If he isn't sub on Saturday I'll be looking to bring him in.

[Jroo]

i will jump on colquhoin if hes not sub

before hes even played a game? Risky

Yeh I've been thinking about it. Is the young tige worth the extra cash? Quinny? JROO? good tiger fans, would be interested in your thoughts.

Hard to say when Sam Col hasn't played a game yet.
Vlastuin should be good though, has said he'll play most of his footy through the midfield and he's tough and can play at AFL level. Also wouldn't expect him to see him as the sub too much.
While with Sam Col, he was scoring well in the U18 comp because he was the loose man, not sure how well he's gone in the SANFL, but if you're planning on bringing in a rookie defender this week, I the it's too risky to go with Sam Col over Vlastuin. If Sam Col scores well you can always trade him in, in a few weeks time.

[bensl]

i would grab vlastuin but that doesn't leave me the cash to upgrade dwyer to daisy.

not sure what to do????????

[quinny88]

Not considering Sierakowski? If he isn't sub on Saturday I'll be looking to bring him in.

Would prefer a rookie on the bubble roo but if he puts in a good performance ill consider him the week after

[sammy123]

i would grab vlastuin but that doesn't leave me the cash to upgrade dwyer to daisy.

not sure what to do????????

agreed. This is my problem too