Who is a good value back selection?

Started by Dave085, May 09, 2013, 06:44:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who is a good value back selection?

H. Shaw
2 (8.3%)
Malceski
0 (0%)
P. Hanley
7 (29.2%)
Scotland
2 (8.3%)
Heppell
13 (54.2%)

Total Members Voted: 2

Dave085

Im wondering who we all think a decent value pick in the backs are at the moment, even for a short term fix.
This is more of a post relevant to my team however I think people could use it as a gauge for theirs as well to bring in a good pick.

Im well aware my backs are stuffed, so no need to remind me ;) Also, I though Pearce might have been a good pickup, he played well in round 1 and I brought him in (was a mistake and a bad early call)
Backs are currently Goddard, Gibbs, D. Pearce, C. Heath, Stevenson, Vlaustin - Emer Terlich and Pittard.

Heath Shaw,
Malceski,
P. Hanley,
Scotland
Heppell

Windigo

For what he can produce, Shaw is the best value. But I'd get in Hepp...

Adamant

As much as I hate him, Shaw is the best value for money... but Hepp/Scotland will average the most easily and are top 6 defenders.

Toga

#3
Shaw the best value for money but won't be a top 6 back...

Heppell > Hanley > Scotland > Shaw for me :-X

Windigo

Quote from: Toga on May 09, 2013, 06:49:16 PM
Shaw the best value for money but won't be a top 5 mid...

Heppell > Hanley > Scotland > Shaw for me :-X


Not a top 6 back.  ;)

powersuperkents

Shower I voted Hanley I didn't see Heppell there  :o disregard a hanley vote and add one to Hep D

Ricochet

I'd still go Hanley over Heppell but Shaw is the best value

Toga

Quote from: Windigo on May 09, 2013, 06:54:43 PM
Quote from: Toga on May 09, 2013, 06:49:16 PM
Shaw the best value for money but won't be a top 5 mid...

Heppell > Hanley > Scotland > Shaw for me :-X


Not a top 6 back.  ;)

Oops, dunno why I wrote mid ::)

HBTD22

I like both Scotland and Heppell. Can't go wrong with either tbh. 8)