Ask Q (3/5/13)

[Master Q]

Hey guys,

As always send me through your questions and I'll give you my honest opinion. Really tough week this week; I haven't even decided what I'm doing, so forgive me if I make some bad calls!

Deadline: 6:35EST (may keep it open a little bit longer)

Cheers
-Q

[nickstiges]

With all this week's carnage some advice is needed (Prioritizing overall over league).

DEF before trades is sitting at: Gibbs, Goddard, Heppell, Goodes, Pittard, Heath (Stevenson, Terlich)

With 539k in the bank my thoughts were:

Option 1: take a donut from Heppell, going Goodes > Hartlett and Blicavs > StevieJ (through Rowe) with 1.5k leftover.

Option 2: Gibbs > Birchall and Goodes/Pittard > Hartlett which would leave me with 280k or 219k to go Stevenson > Gibbs and Heath > Vlastuin next week.

Option 3: Goodes > Birchall and Pittard > Hartlett with 42k leftover and 5 premo backs if they all play.

Not sure if it's worth missing out on SJ or take a donut and have a pretty nice looking FWD line.

Thoughts? And if option 2 which of Goodes/Pittard to trade?

[HBTD22]

Haha why not. Your choice outta Waters or Hartlett?

[bob321]

who do you think will score the most this week?
hartlett vs north
scotland vs melb
birchall vs crows

[Master Q]

With all this week's carnage some advice is needed (Prioritizing overall over league).

DEF before trades is sitting at: Gibbs, Goddard, Heppell, Goodes, Pittard, Heath (Stevenson, Terlich)

With 539k in the bank my thoughts were:

Option 1: take a donut from Heppell, going Goodes > Hartlett and Blicavs > StevieJ (through Rowe) with 1.5k leftover.

Option 2: Gibbs > Birchall and Goodes/Pittard > Hartlett which would leave me with 280k or 219k to go Stevenson > Gibbs and Heath > Vlastuin next week.

Option 3: Goodes > Birchall and Pittard > Hartlett with 42k leftover and 5 premo backs if they all play.

Not sure if it's worth missing out on SJ or take a donut and have a pretty nice looking FWD line.

Thoughts? And if option 2 which of Goodes/Pittard to trade?

I'm also considering Donut or Stevie J, but if you can get two premiums in this week in Option 3, and avoid a donut, why not?

Haha why not. Your choice outta Waters or Hartlett?

Haven't been a fan of Hartlett all year but I'm starting to give in. I'd go with him.

[HBTD22]

Haven't been a fan of Hartlett all year but I'm starting to give in. I'd go with him.

Cheers mate. Maybe I'll flip a coin on it ;)

[Master Q]

who do you think will score the most this week?
hartlett vs north
scotland vs melb
birchall vs crows

Scotland might do a lot of mopping up on Sunday. Think Birchall and Hartlett are in for some average weekends but are not a reason to turn off them.

[nickstiges]

I'm also considering Donut or Stevie J, but if you can get two premiums in this week in Option 3, and avoid a donut, why not?

Guess I'll have to give up on SJ, for this week at least and make the decision between keeping Gibbs or Goodes, cheers for the advice :)

[KoopKicka]

ok Q, I have 6 rd 12 bye players, if Im trading out Gibbs do I bring in Waters (rd 12) or Scotland (rd 13)?

[bob321]

who do you think will score the most this week?
hartlett vs north
scotland vs melb
birchall vs crows

Scotland might do a lot of mopping up on Sunday. Think Birchall and Hartlett are in for some average weekends but are not a reason to turn off them.

thanks mate

[Master Q]

ok Q, I have 6 rd 12 bye players, if Im trading out Gibbs do I bring in Waters (rd 12) or Scotland (rd 13)?

Shouldn't worry about byes, but I'd go Scotland over Waters anyway.

[Flame]

Q- I want need to replace Gibbs and want to get  Birch but I think he is too expensive! I'm liking Scotland vs Melb!

So thinking of Goodes or Pittard to Saunders or Vlast??

Thoughts??

[jamfrank]

Hey Q,

Should I do a double sideways this round: Fyfe/Gibbs-->Scotland/Hartlett

or should one of those be a downgrade. If I do the above trade, I'm left with $418k (so not exactly a pauper)

[Master Q]

Q- I want need to replace Gibbs and want to get  Birch but I think he is too expensive! I'm liking Scotland vs Melb!

So thinking of Goodes or Pittard to Saunders or Vlast??

Thoughts??

Think Vlast might have a little bit more JS.

Hey Q,

Should I do a double sideways this round: Fyfe/Gibbs-->Scotland/Hartlett

or should one of those be a downgrade. If I do the above trade, I'm left with $418k (so not exactly a pauper)

All about improving the team and not plugging the holes IMO. So if you can get a rookie up to a premium this week, go for it.

[Flame]

Q- I want need to replace Gibbs and want to get  Birch but I think he is too expensive! I'm liking Scotland vs Melb!

So thinking of Goodes or Pittard to Saunders or Vlast??

Thoughts??

Think Vlast might have a little bit more JS.

Hey Q,

Should I do a double sideways this round: Fyfe/Gibbs-->Scotland/Hartlett

or should one of those be a downgrade. If I do the above trade, I'm left with $418k (so not exactly a pauper)

All about improving the team and not plugging the holes IMO. So if you can get a rookie up to a premium this week, go for it.

So you're happy with Scotland?? I could just afford Birch!!