Dwyer vs Evans (vs Neade)

Started by DTCoach, May 03, 2013, 03:54:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

DTCoach

Assuming Evans is selected (extended bench) and Dwyer avoids the vest tonight who goes on field?

I think Evans all things equal would be my pick but would he be a sub risk and would the safety of knowing if Dwyer is in green override any advantage Evans otherwise has? Neade is the outsider for mine of these (lower score potential than Evans and not the benefit of Dwyer on knowing if in the vest)

Would be a non issue if it weren't for Chappy!

Windigo

Evans
Neade
Dywer

Neade has been pretty solid, but the green vest has to be coming his way soon...

Kane might get it, but surely he get's a full game!   :o

fertalong

Evans plays carlton and they will get smashed so i'd expect a 60-65 score from him.
Dwyer can go anywhere between 50-80
Neade 55-70

Neade and Dwyer are both red vest candidates you would think.

I would pick Evans out of the lot, but the point difference will be minimal.

Discombobulated

I expect that Evans will be named, and per the previous comments I see Neade as a vest candidate.  Dwyer's output of late has concerned me more than his risk of a vest.  So he's warming pine, mainly so I can maintain a DPP link with my FWD line.

RookieDTer

Quote from: Discombobulated on May 03, 2013, 04:23:43 PM
I expect that Evans will be named, and per the previous comments I see Neade as a vest candidate.  Dwyer's output of late has concerned me more than his risk of a vest.  So he's warming pine, mainly so I can maintain a DPP link with my FWD line.
KMitchell has not been setting the world on fire in the SANFL and was a vest in 3/3 matches he played..... He'd have to be the most likley best candidate in any team this week?

Windigo

Is Evans a confirmed in?

Has the Melb team been updated yet?

Windigo

Just came through:

IN: Lynden Dunn, James Strauss, Jake Spencer, Jack Viney, Dean Kent, Daniel Nicholson

OUT: Mark Jamar (groin), Jack Watts (hamstring), David Rodan, Aaron Davey, Sam Blease, Cameron Pedersen

DTCoach

good news, think ill go evans. Plenty of green vest candidates for dees, especially with so many changes, so hopefully he avoids it