Help Nrich round 6 (Cheers if you help)

Started by nrich102, May 02, 2013, 07:39:52 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who to trade in for Gibbs?

Hartlett
10 (55.6%)
Waters
2 (11.1%)
Grimes
0 (0%)
Don't trade Gibbs out
6 (33.3%)

Total Members Voted: 0

nrich102

Hey guys, here's my team-

DEF: Birchall, Goddard, Gibbs, Heath, Duffield, Terlich, Goodes, Pittard
MID: Swan, GAJ, Pendles, Lids, Wines, Moloney, O'Meara, Viney, Dwyer, Evans
RUC: Roughy, Luey
FWD: Rocky, JJK, Cox, Bartel, Zorko, Mayes, Neade, Rowe

$11,300 left in the bank.

So, I'm planning on doing Gibbs --> Hartlett/Waters/Grimes (Vote in the poll). I'm not sure what to do for my second trade though. I could do Roughy --> Goldstein or trade out Goodes or Pittard to ??. Or Blicavs --> Gawn, who will probably do more rucking, with Jamar out.

Cheers.

blues boy

how much money do you have in the bank??

Is it worth trading Gibbs out if he is going to miss just one game?

dicey7

ive thought about getting hartlett alot this week but i just cant help but feel that his hamstrings will give way at some point

HBTD22

Why not Pittard/Goodes to a rook and then Gibbs > Scotland? Scotland has Melb this week and should demolish them (assuming he survives the Sunday bench cut haha). Hold on to Roughy, you're better off saving a doughnut when its not needed.

slipknot_4

I would trade him out to someone with a low BE so either Hartlett or Grimes. I voted Hartlett, Red hot form so far and still very low BE.

nrich102

Quote from: blues boy on May 02, 2013, 07:42:42 PM
how much money do you have in the bank??

Is it worth trading Gibbs out if he is going to miss just one game?
Oops, sorry for not putting that in. It's in now

Senior

I'm in a similar situation to you having to do Gibbs -> Hartlett & Pittard -> Vlastuin or else i'll cop a donut!

I reckon Hartlett is the best option out of those 3, has averaged 111 not counting his 35 against GWS and he is playing in the midfield a lot more then last year. He looked really good last week against the eagles, in the second half he was awesome! He has a low b/e of 47 so he'll go up in price a lot in next few weeks too!  :) 

auscoyote

AC predictions over next 2 rounds

Hartlett  + 28k
Waters   - 35K
Grimes    - 5k

I would go with hartlett, or grimes for a POD

Aaron8

Gibbs - Hartlett and Pittard - Vlastuin?

blues boy

Quote from: Aaron8 on May 02, 2013, 08:09:23 PM
Gibbs - Hartlett and Pittard - Vlastuin?

Agree with this ^^^ but

Gibbs ----> Hartlett
Pittard or Goodes ----> Vlastiun or J. Saunders (if he doesnt get the green vest)

Jormas

I've got 165k in the bank and am going:

Goodes -> Harlett and Viney -> Saunders (Gibbs to mids)

and in the backline i bench Frost and Hepps.

Playing backline this week: Goddard, Hartlett, Hanley, Stevenson, Terlich, Saunders (Hepps, Frost)

Hopefully nek week i can go Neade -> Gray and maybe Dwyer to Cachia or even Frost -> Vlastuin (if i have the coin)

blues boy

Quote from: Jormas on May 02, 2013, 08:18:55 PM
I've got 165k in the bank and am going:

Goodes -> Harlett and Viney -> Saunders (Gibbs to mids)

and in the backline i bench Frost and Hepps.

Playing backline this week: Goddard, Hartlett, Hanley, Stevenson, Terlich, Saunders (Hepps, Frost)

Hopefully nek week i can go Neade -> Gray and maybe Dwyer to Cachia or even Frost -> Vlastuin (if i have the coin)

Viney still has some money to make and is named this week, so why get rid of him?
If he was not playing i would agree with you

Jormas

Either Viney or Crouch. And Viney's BE is around about 35, IMO he will get 50 odd against Essendon and end up going up only 5/10k

Plus, he's bench warming anyway, when i have 4 not playing down back, so what's the point in having him if i could change him to some points (saunders)

its me lads

IMO you shouldnt trade out Gibbs, especially if you plan on bringing him back in. Could be too hard to bring him back in. Also trade Goodes out. 2 weeks for someone like him is a killer, has to be traded out.

blues boy

Quote from: its me lads on May 02, 2013, 08:53:35 PM
IMO you shouldnt trade out Gibbs, especially if you plan on bringing him back in. Could be too hard to bring him back in. Also trade Goodes out. 2 weeks for someone like him is a killer, has to be traded out.

So much more money to be made with Goodes though

I am tossing up between Vlastiun and Saunders for Pittard