Hello Kommer, heres GWS to play

Started by grimreaper, May 01, 2013, 07:27:32 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

powersuperkents

Quote from: glynman on May 01, 2013, 11:39:58 PM
Quote from: powersuperkents on May 01, 2013, 11:37:03 PM
Just because it's GWS doesn't mean Kommer will do well haha. Even if he does play he'll be my emergency. I am going to field Evans over him because he isn't very good. Hopefully he reaches $250k after byes so I can downgrade him

Yeh I'd play Evans over him too. Also could have Mayes in mids then play Macaffer on the field so effectively that would mean Macaffer over Evans. Does Macaffer > Evans > Kommer look right?
I moved Cox into my rucks this week so I wouldn't have to play Rowe. This way I could field Macaffer and Dwyer. I rate Macaffer > Dwyer. But Evans > Macaffer in my honest opinion. I would also consider Kommer > Macaffer if Kommer is named to start because at least Kommer is a guaranteed 60. I think Evans also will most likely be a guaranteed 60 whilst the Caf is as well. It's pretty much a guessing game Kommer is 60 & 65, Evans is 58, 111 & 67 and the caf is 50, 66, 64 & 60. It's honestly too tough to decide. Evans has the highers ceiling so pick him and on second thought Caf is more reliable than Kommer not to obtain a vest so Evans > Caf > Kommer. Really Caf for consistency (not always the case) & Evans for ceiling (rare occurrence)

Andrew

Quote from: Mr.Craig on May 01, 2013, 10:52:39 PM
Does anyone else see the irony in the thread title?


HA love it! And Cometti's call during Essendon's round 1 win:

"Kommer puts an exclamation mark on this win!"

May Kommer have a long career :)

Ricochet

Quote from: Andrew on May 02, 2013, 12:26:16 AM
Quote from: Mr.Craig on May 01, 2013, 10:52:39 PM
Does anyone else see the irony in the thread title?


HA love it! And Cometti's call during Essendon's round 1 win:

"Kommer puts an exclamation mark on this win!"

May Kommer have a long career :)

haha I liked his "Inverted Kommer" call when he got dumped on his head

grimreaper

I don't think Kommers last score does him justice for the work he done, I really rate him and hope it shows against GWS. I can't see any reason why he won't be named.

disco1992

I know the in the mix article is shower but there was no mention of him playing

Ricochet

Yeh after that long off they'd probably give him a run in the twos to prove himself again. Its not like he is an established player like Watson/Stanton/etc

milisha98

Now that Winderlich is back and playing well in the same position (scored a ton last week against Collingwood), I don't see where Kommer fits in the side to be honest.

LF

Kommer maybe the new Relton
I hope not tho because I held him as well mainly because I had other stuff to fix first.

Bones Bombers

#23
Jackson Merret may get a rest to give Kommer a game. Think these two rookies will be interchangeable as long as Licka is fit.
Like Kommer's physicality better than Merret's.

disco1992

appoligies for my doubts, named on the ball

grimreaper

I've watched him closely, no way he wasn't going to be named..  :)

Thorpy

Pretty happy that I left him on the bench but like many above me have said they left him there because that had more important priorities same goes with myself! Just happy the majority of my rookies are making me cash $$$  :D

powersuperkents

He's in forward pocket :) I was happy when I saw him on the ball but this is much better. Playing GWS hopefully he can bag 3-4 goals :)

Ricochet


Bak2Form

glad i got rid of him when he got suspended ;)