Dixon worth trading in

[LF]

Looking at the same backline situation as everyone else Gibbs,Pittard and Goodes out

Considering trading Dwyer-->Dixon and move Goodes to mids bench for now.
Thoughts on Dixon can he keep up his scoring he is looking really good atm.

[bslinger]

Given Dixon is GCS's most dangerous forward, i'd assume McPharlin would get the job on him? So based on that i'd say no.

[jamfrank]

The beauty of Dixon is that when he's not kicking bags of goals he's earning points through hit outs. The question you have to ask is if his early season form is a flash in the pan or is this his season?

I'm leaning towards the former and don't think it will continue for Dixon. Against quality defenders such as McPharlin I don't think he'll score as well.

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

there are much better options buddy ;)

Birchall, Hanley, Hartlett, Burgoyne even - all proven scorers!

[pommyadam]

there are much better options buddy ;)

Birchall, Hanley, Hartlett, Burgoyne even - all proven scorers!

cause they're on a similar price level?
all those players (Hanley and Burgoyne) are 100k more than Dixon, with Birchall being 150k more
it's like comparing Wines with Watson

[HBTD22]

I wouldn't jump on Dixon just yet. Maybe next season.

[Ricochet]

Has McPharlin this week but then will get Frawley (Brown 3.1, Cameron 1.0, Kennedy 5.3, Shulz 4.0)

[TMurphBROWNLOW]

there are much better options buddy ;)

Birchall, Hanley, Hartlett, Burgoyne even - all proven scorers!

cause they're on a similar price level?
all those players (Hanley and Burgoyne) are 100k more than Dixon, with Birchall being 150k more
it's like comparing Wines with Watson

exactly, you wouldn't trade Wines into your squad just because he's scoring well, over Watson.

[Andrew]

there are much better options buddy ;)

Birchall, Hanley, Hartlett, Burgoyne even - all proven scorers!

cause they're on a similar price level?
all those players (Hanley and Burgoyne) are 100k more than Dixon, with Birchall being 150k more
it's like comparing Wines with Watson

exactly, you wouldn't trade Wines into your squad just because he's scoring well, over Watson.

Well said, TMurph.

[Money]

No from me mate, just don't think he's worth the trade, let alone trading him in..

[LF]

there are much better options buddy ;)

Birchall, Hanley, Hartlett, Burgoyne even - all proven scorers!

cause they're on a similar price level?
all those players (Hanley and Burgoyne) are 100k more than Dixon, with Birchall being 150k more
it's like comparing Wines with Watson

exactly, you wouldn't trade Wines into your squad just because he's scoring well, over Watson.

You are comparing a rookie to someone who is not.Dixon is not a rookie so your comparison of Wines and Watson is completely invalid.

[chaosAD]

No