Nat Fyfe Report?

Started by Juddster5, April 26, 2013, 11:43:28 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Toga

Lol, + flowering 1 RookieDTer

That would be the most logical action... ::) ;D

me

u guys actually played footy? pretty easy from the couch to say what a bloke should do to get some mongrel tagger off of him

nrich102

Quote from: me on April 27, 2013, 11:12:24 AM
u guys actually played footy? pretty easy from the couch to say what a bloke should do to get some mongrel tagger off of him
Yes, I do. I would not kick anyone intentionally. I would push them off me.

Quote from: Toga on April 27, 2013, 10:49:41 AM
Lol, + flowering 1 RookieDTer

That would be the most logical action... ::) ;D
+2

me

yeah well i do, and i can definitely see how this can happen - not saying it would do it myself and definitely wouldn't be regular practice (i've literally never seen fyfe do anything report worthy, so it wouldn't be regular practice for him either) , but i can definitely understand how if you're being hounded/manhandled by a tagger stuff like this can happen

also, you say push him off, but taggers are usually pretty strong guys, and especially if they're sitting on top of you, they're not easy to just simply "push off" lol

guess we'll just have to see what the mrp comes up with

Toga

Haha look, I don't disagree with you that it would be frustrating as flower having a tagger sit on top of you, you are absolutely right there! But not sure kicking him in the kidneys is the right thing to do! ;)

Also I'm not convinced Jackson was sitting on top of him, from what i recall of the footage he was getting up from a tackle and Fyfe kicks him.

Anyways we will just have to wait for the MRP report.

elephants

Quote from: its me lads on April 27, 2013, 12:07:12 AM
Umpire might of reported him for not doing anything in the last quarter, maybe he had him in his dt.  ;D

Hahahah, good call ;D

Toga

Fyfe gone for 1, doesn't surprise me I must say

its me lads

didnt see the incident but YOU HAVE GOT TO BE KIDDING ME!!!!

Spinking

Quote from: RookieDTer on April 27, 2013, 10:47:08 AM
Quote
i meant kick/push/whatever force required to get the guy off - if not how do you suggest he gets up? is he just supposed to lie on the ground and wait until jackson chooses to let him up? (meanwhile the game is going on)

meh
Hmmm, how about pushing him off?

Lol. Good call!

LF

Sounds like Freo are going to challenge it by what Lyon said tonight on 6pr

me

#25
lol how does fyfe get a week and boyd gets off ?? boyd smashes selwood with far more force than fyfe uses in basically pushing jackson off with his boot........................... mrp is a flowering joke (like we haven't said that before about them) - as some guy said on bigfooty, fyfe should challenge and get the same qc who got shuey off for elbowing thomas last year

edit: good luvfooty, they should challenge and beat it easy

Toga

In all honesty I don't think it was a good move at all by him.

Jackson tackled, and gets up pretty much straight away with a bit of a push on Fyfe to get up. Fyfe takes the push and then looks at Jackson before jabbing his boot into Jackson's stomach..

I thought Fyfe would be copping a week, maybe two from the get go, and completely agree with the MRP's review; intentional, low impact, body contact.

I love Fyfey as a player but think the MRP has done the right thing here, they don't wanna be letting cheap and dirty body kicks like that off otherwise they're sending the wrong message.

its me lads

Jackson wasn't doing much but Fyfe hardly touched him.... Boyd hit Selwood harder.

me

lol and also what about helbig intentionally stepping on danyle pearce's hand... definitely sending a good message there

helbig could have done far more damage with his boot than what fyfe could have done with his

its me lads

Quote from: me on April 29, 2013, 08:59:58 PM
lol and also what about helbig intentionally stepping on danyle pearce's hand... definitely sending a good message there

helbig could have done far more damage with his boot than what fyfe could have done with his

+1

Fyfe didnt kick Jackson to hurt him, he did it to get him off. Helbig stepping on Pearces hand? Thats just stupid and trying to inflict pain.