Help Nrich Round 3 (Cheers if you comment)

[nrich102]

OK guys, here's my team.

DEF:Gibbs, Goddard, B. Goodes, Stevenson, Duffman, Pittard (Heath, Terlich)
MID:Swan, Pendles, GAJ, Murphy, Lids, Wines, O'Meara, Viney (Toumpas, Crouch)
RUC:Roughy, Berger (Daw, Blicavs)
FWD:Bartel, Rocky, Cox, JJK, Zorko, Dwyer (Macaffer, Neade )

So I want to trade out Jimmy 'the spud' Toumpas and Maccaffer. Here are my options:

a) Trade Toumpas to Mayes and Maccaffer to Rowe
b) Trade Toumpas to Mayes and Maccaffer to Sinclair
c) Trade Toumpas to Mayes and Maccaffer to Lee
d) Trade Toumpas to Rampe and Maccaffer to Rowe
e) Trade Toumpas to Rampe and Maccaffer to Sinclair
f) Trade Toumpas to Rampe and Maccaffer to Lee
g) Something else (Please comment)

Thanks in advance

[Windigo]

Toump->Mayes & Zorko->Premo.

?

[nrich102]

Toump->Mayes & Zorko->Premo.

?

I think Ill give Zorko one more week. $239,600 left in the bank, but saving it for Zorko

[gunnerzzz]

I'd bring in Rowe for his dpp. Scored alright last week too. Dunno about all the other rooks JS wise!

[fertalong]

Zorko -> Hoff
Caff -> Rowe

Wait until Mayes is on the bubble before bringing him in. He should do well again this week, but you just never know.

[henry]

Yeah, I'd definitely go with rowe for macaffer, has good JS especially with kruezer now out for a month and has scored reasonably. He should avoid the vests (perhaps red occaisionly) and make a fair deal of cash.

With the other trade I'd get rid of zorko for stevie J or buddy (the hoff if you want to risk it) or if you want to keep him then if you can afford it toumpas to moloney or mullet.

Mayes looks very good but I'd wait a week on him, same with Lee.

[Flame]

I like option a! I'm giving Zorko one more week too!

[Ricochet]

Toumpas to Merrett from Essendon? Averaging 68 and BE of -61
Then look at Mayes next week maybe.

And Macaffer to Rowe is the obvious one.

[nrich102]

Toumpas to Merrett from Essendon? Averaging 68 and BE of -61
Then look at Mayes next week maybe.

And Macaffer to Rowe is the obvious one.

Doesn't sound as such a bad idea

[henry]

Toumpas to Merrett from Essendon? Averaging 68 and BE of -61
Then look at Mayes next week maybe.

And Macaffer to Rowe is the obvious one.

Doesn't sound as such a bad idea

My concern with that would be the likelihood of a vest and JS, he only came in because the bombers had 3 or 4 suspensions or injuries I think, so will likely be vested when he does play and will probably be dropped in the next couple of weeks when those guys come back. I guess then you could get kommer though, who has a negative be and with only 1 price rise so far is 130k,

[its me lads]

Voted for the last one and here are my suggestions.

Personally i think Zorko has to go, different role and just not looking good at all. I think Toumpas will do alright against GWS, his b/e is 54 which isn't ideal but I think he'll get it.

If you didn't have crouch I would suggest Toumpas -> Crouch but you do have him so maybe wait a week on Toumpas and do

Zorko-->Westhoff + Macaffer -->Rowe
Zorko-->Martin + Macaffer -->Rowe
Zorko-->Lecras + Macaffer -->Rowe

depending on what you want, Westhoff- Make money, possible keeper
Martin-- Keeper
lecras--Get cash from downgrade and make money with a possible keeper option.

Although if you forced me to choose one of your option I would choose option A, bringing in Rowe on the bubble and Mayes looks quality would go alright.

[Crustynuts]

I'd go (and have):

Zorko ---> Westhoff (or another "premo")
Macaffer ---> Rowe

[nrich102]

I have decided to do option A.