Gibbs or J.Selwood?

[Bmo23]

Gibbs or J.Selwood? who would you choose as 4th mid?

[fyfebe]

gibbs

[mog_dog00]

yea tough pick but im with gibbs, but prob gonna regret not having selwood cos im not planning on upgrading to get him

[TEHCOON]

selwood everyday of the week

[Cool9]

Selwood.
I think Gibbs is still another year away, perhaps two. Selwood could one of the best midfielders in the AFL by season-end if last years form is anything to go by.

[Bmo23]

i might have to downgrade one of ablett, bartel, or judd to get them both. still cant decide. but slighty leaning towards selwood.

[bjrouse]

Why would you want to downgrade any of those 3 for Gibbs or Selwood

[Bo]

Ball. NEXT

[peanut]

Gibbs. one of the best kicks in the game and will spend even more time in the midfield this year.

Saying that I have both.
Ablett, Pendlebury, salopek, Selwood, Gibbs, Wells.

what do we all think about wells, wouldn't normally touch him but his price seems right.   

[Marcus]

Being a cats fan I love Selwood.
I feel both will hit about an average of 110 though.
As Gibbs is quite a bit cheaper than Selwood. I'd personally be going for Gibbs.
Both are premiums that will get you hundreds on a fairly regular basis so wooo :).

[Marcus]

Just watched Selwood.
I retract my previous statement.
Get the hell on Selwood :).

[Bmo23]

yeah nab gf confirmed it for me. selwood all the way. saying that will be watchin gibbs real closely though