Which 2 rookies to trade in

[antonc]

Ok
Want to bring in 2 rooks on the bubble this week.
Considering all 3, but wondering about scoring potential and job security in the next 4 to 6 weeks.
All will be short team prospects for my team. They will be moved on when their BE blows out.
Only Terlich would start on the field if I would bring them in


PS Starting to like these 44 trades!! ;)

[Toga]

I started with Terlich, so for me, it will be Crouch and Rowe...

Rowe probably only has good JS in the short term seeing as he could be pushed out of the side by the returning Waite/Casboult/Kreuzer, but that will be in 3+ weeks time.

Would you be putting Rowe in the Rucks or Forwards? If its the forwards, how many rookies you starting on the field atm?

[Nicko06]

Do people think Terlich has pretty good JS and won't be getting the green/red vest anytime soon?
haven't seen many Melbourne mathces..

[Toga]

I think one of the younger guys would be first in line for the vest tbh... Think Terlich's maturity and great kicking skills would be wasted if he were to be used as the sub.

But who knows what Melbourne might do the next couple of weeks. :o

[Ricochet]

Crouch and Rowe for me
WIth VB out for the crows and Kruez, Waite still out for the Blues they both probably have the best JS

[antonc]

Rowe probably only has good JS in the short term seeing as he could be pushed out of the side by the returning Waite/Casboult/Kreuzer, but that will be in 3+ weeks time.
Not too worried about this although would prob like him to play for at least the next 3 weeks

Would you be putting Rowe in the Rucks or Forwards? If its the forwards, how many rookies you starting on the field atm?

Can put Rowe in either Ruck or Forward (Daw or Patton) if Patton doesn't go this week he will next week for Mayes
7 starting rooks/rookie priced players including wines and B.Goodes

[Windigo]

I'd go Terlich & Crouch.

Although Rowe's JS went through the roof recently... :-\


Maybe Rowe & Crouch then!  :P

[fidou]

I am bringing only one rook this week and after seeing Terlich's dismal kicking in on AFL 360 (why give a 2nd gamer that responsibility) am thinking of Hutchins.

Not much talk on him atm. I thought his was quite good in 2011 and had a horror stretch of injuries in 2012. Does anyone know his current status or have seen him play this year.

[Ricochet]

I am bringing only one rook this week and after seeing Terlich's dismal kicking in on AFL 360 (why give a 2nd gamer that responsibility) am thinking of Hutchins.

Not much talk on him atm. I thought his was quite good in 2011 and had a horror stretch of injuries in 2012. Does anyone know his current status or have seen him play this year.

I was just reading about Hutchins on the SC board. Some boys seem to have a bit of insight
http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,78054.0.html

[antonc]

Thanks mate. Might consider Hutchins now.
As for Daw he will be staying in my team ;)

[Dutchie64]

I posted  a thread about Hutchins a few days ago.

He's playing this week-end and seeing I had Vlastuin on the bench I've traded him for J. Hutchins to make me some cash.

Seems like a a good option to me and McKenna seems to rate him

[Rommas]

I went Terlich over Pittard this week  ::) then he had to go score 95 against Gold Coast