Jack Grimes!!

Started by Migy119, April 16, 2013, 09:58:35 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Migy119

What to do with him?? i can upgrade to any defender

his not averaging what i want but what do u think KEEP OR SELL

HBTD22

 Keep your guns. Will consistently average 80+ this season if he stays fit.

Migy119

so u wouldnt upgrade him to handely or birchel!!!
if i dont maybe upgrade a cash cow to him like a pittard or stevenson??  but when they hit there peek

what do ya think?

Holz

Quote from: Migy119 on April 16, 2013, 10:08:05 PM
so u wouldnt upgrade him to handely or birchel!!!
if i dont maybe upgrade a cash cow to him like a pittard or stevenson??  but when they hit there peek

what do ya think?

unless you have more pressing issues definitely do the trade, Melbourne are dismal at the moment and there are very few players who could post consistently good DT scores in that team. We have 2 trades a week so use them.

Hanley is pretty much a straight swap and he wil keep going up in value. Grimes will drop untill the dees get their act together. You can always bring in grimes in a few rounds when he is around 420k. 

Migy119

but the problem is.. if i bring in handely this week ill miss rowe or sincler

cause i went daw to sincler   and
varcoe to rowe

what do u think i should do?

thanks so much!!

Chelskiman

I have him and I'm keeping him for now.  His scores certainly aren't premium right now but I think once Melbourne get their act together he'll be fine.  Has a soft game this week and I expect a score of 90+.  I have noticed he's doing a bit of Dusty lately though.  He'll be on track for a ton at half time then go completely missing.  If he can get 4 quarters together he can easily go on a run of games where he's grabbing scores of 95+ consistently.

Ricochet

Quote from: Migy119 on April 16, 2013, 10:22:14 PM
but the problem is.. if i bring in handely this week ill miss rowe or sincler

cause i went daw to sincler   and
varcoe to rowe

what do u think i should do?

thanks so much!!
Sinclair isn't really worth it but I would jump on Rowe.
If you have no other issues with your side I would definitely sideways trade to Hanley

Migy119

Yer I will thanks so much lads!!  ;D

HBTD22

Quote from: Migy119 on April 16, 2013, 10:08:05 PM
so u wouldnt upgrade him to handely or birchel!!!
if i dont maybe upgrade a cash cow to him like a pittard or stevenson??  but when they hit there peek

what do ya think?

I wouldn't. Hanley is bipolar in DT as previous years have shown. You can rely on Jack to bang out 75+ every round.

Holz

Quote from: HBTD22 on April 17, 2013, 11:43:50 AM
Quote from: Migy119 on April 16, 2013, 10:08:05 PM
so u wouldnt upgrade him to handely or birchel!!!
if i dont maybe upgrade a cash cow to him like a pittard or stevenson??  but when they hit there peek

what do ya think?

I wouldn't. Hanley is bipolar in DT as previous years have shown. You can rely on Jack to bang out 75+ every round.

the difference this year is he looks to keep his firendly DT role. I picked him with prediction he would average 90+ over the first 6-7 rounds and so far he is outeforming that. wherec not picknig him just on his past 3 scores but he was looking like a good pick all preseason and is showing why.

you dont need sinclair.

Alka

Reasons not to trade:
They're playing GWS, if he's going to score well any week this'll be it.

His first three games last year: 66, 65, 65.
He then went on to average 96.4.

You would have been spewing if you jumped ship early last year. I'm sticking for now.


Holz

Quote from: Alka on April 17, 2013, 01:08:53 PM
Reasons not to trade:
They're playing GWS, if he's going to score well any week this'll be it.

His first three games last year: 66, 65, 65.
He then went on to average 96.4.

You would have been spewing if you jumped ship early last year. I'm sticking for now.

he was carrying an injury coming into the season last year, thats why his scores were poor. He is 100% fully fit this year and had a full preseason. He is underpeforming as the dees suck, unless you think they will be competetive from here on drop him and pick him up later.

Hanley is scoring big on everyone and he has north and dees up, two freindly DT teams.