Reverse?

[Jackross10]

I went lee --- Dwyer
Should I reverse and go Macaffer --- Dwyer seeing as his not playing and lee is

[quinny88]

Same issue. Interested to see peoples thoughts

[quinny88]

Whats your gut feel jackross?

[Jackross10]

Yeah ! I am !

[Darbium]

I can't see Lee staying in the Saints best 22.  Stick with Lee to Dwyer

[Lions01]

Hard choice

I'd be very tempted to go Caffer to Dwyer, Fasolo plays a simular role to Macaffer (might hold him out for a while). However it's a friendly reminder of how competitive spots are at Collingwood

[quinny88]

I can't see Lee staying in the Saints best 22.  Stick with Lee to Dwyer

What makes you say that? They used a high draft pick to get him and hes mature aged. I was shocked he wasnt in right from round 1

[Footyrulz]

macaffer to dwyer!!!!! macaffer will be lucky to play again this year!!

[Marcon]

Hmm, your both in a rather awkward spot, but if it was me id give caff the boot and hold lee, purely for JS reasons. Macaffer had his chance, and in my opinion blew it. Collingwood is a hard team break into. Whereas Lee on the otherhand, i think will be given a decent chance to devalop and show his worth, and in this time, he will everyone that has him and appropriate amount of cash.

But hey, thats just me

[Mat0369]

The other thing that I would look at is that Kosi had an injury in the VFL. I am not sure how serious it was, but that takes off the immediate pressure on Lee that Kosi will take his spot. I see Macaffer struggling to get a game with Thomas, Fasolo and co into the 22 and now he has to compete with Didak and Krak for a spot. Will be very tough.

[bonebones]

Macaffer has had a slow but solid start. Just needs to improve his fitness. He's a premiership player and will get back In to the side - maybe even on Sunday.  Why would you trade out Lee when he is getting his debut? I don't think those types of trades will net you anything.  Dwyer looks set for a few more weeks though, but If the pies get slammed this week you can expect players like Dyer and Russell to go. Tough call especially with 30 trades up our sleeves!

[Redbaron]

I would not be keen on either of those trades what is the rest of your team like

[Jackross10]

After the trades .....

Goddard Gibbs Hanley Goodes Pittard brown.    Stevenson Heath

Ablett Pendlebury JPK JSelwood Fyfe Wines O'Meara Viney.      Kommer Jones

Leunberger Jacobs.        Daw Blicavs

Franklin cox Zorko Ryder JJK Dwyer.     Neade lee

[Redbaron]

Tough choice macaffer goes up 40 kommer goes up 40k, Dwyer goes up 80k ,lee??? If you trade purely on unknown factor, would be lee and also opportunity to get lee in 2 weeks time again if he carves it up.
Only 2 codices based on what we know right now. Pass on Dwyer as an unfortunate miss due to circumstances, or Lee

Goodluck tough call

[tigertops]

lee is in caffer not.
saints are struggling and if lee plays decently there is a spot there for him.
caffer has alot of competition for his spot now. fasolo and the young guys elliot dwyer even josh thomas....
dont like caffers outlook as all

keep lee out caffer i say..