what to do with K. Mitchell?

Started by bensl, April 11, 2013, 08:06:33 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

bensl

what to do with this bloke?  it would seem like a no brainer if you didnt have one of the "must haves" but ignoring these who would you bring in or would you hang tight for a while.

my mid rooks are viney, wines, crouch & omeara.

cheers

Slick5

Im in the same situation and leaning towards trading him for Sam Dwyer, who is set to rise $86k after the weekend, plus it would give me a midfield link to the forward line which could be handy.

nrich102


Ringo

Mitchell to Dwyer is sound.  Other alternative is Jones.

Holz

mitchell to jones is a much better move.

Jones looks like he has very solid JS.

bensl

i will be putting dwyer in my forward line for karnezsis.

i hadnt looked at jones - thanks

Torpedo10

I'm holding on Mitchell and waiting for Crouch to be on the bubble. I see Crouch as a must have if he plays.

GCSkiwi

Quote from: Holzman on April 11, 2013, 10:15:10 AM
mitchell to jones is a much better move.

Jones looks like he has very solid JS.

See I'm torn - Maybe Jones has better JS but Dwyer I don't think Dwyer would be first in line to be dropped at the Pies... And His scores have been better than Jones, so he could potentially be a great short term cash cow to offload before bye rounds. Guess it depends on your team makeup and whether you're going for a short or long term strategy...
I think I will consider Jones purely because Dwyer would make 4 Pies in my team, with round 13 being the bye for many of my key prems... But then if I wait until rd 13 to offload him, I skip byes from rd 11 and 12 players :P Hard decision.

arbel

Quote from: GCSkiwi on April 11, 2013, 11:08:51 AM
Quote from: Holzman on April 11, 2013, 10:15:10 AM
mitchell to jones is a much better move.

Jones looks like he has very solid JS.

See I'm torn - Maybe Jones has better JS but Dwyer I don't think Dwyer would be first in line to be dropped at the Pies... And His scores have been better than Jones, so he could potentially be a great short term cash cow to offload before bye rounds. Guess it depends on your team makeup and whether you're going for a short or long term strategy...
I think I will consider Jones purely because Dwyer would make 4 Pies in my team, with round 13 being the bye for many of my key prems... But then if I wait until rd 13 to offload him, I skip byes from rd 11 and 12 players :P Hard decision.

What people have to remember is that Dwyer is an elevated rookie for Broomhead while he is on the LTI list.
As soon as Brromhead gets taken off the LTI it doesn't matter how good he is playing etc he must go back onto the rookie list and can only play again if they put someone else on the LTI and upgrade him again.

I have him, i think it's a no brainer to have him in. Broomhead is supposed to be out for about 6 weeks still. So get him in to make money for that time and trade hime out once he tops out on price.

FOOTY IS BACK

With the extra trades this year im willing to trade Mitchell-jones  and trade karny to dwyer........... blow a couple of trades that could see you make 400k or more is well worth it

bensl

thoughts on matt jones v jackson merrett?

Mahogany

I want to trade Mitchell to Crouch as he's the only "must have" I dont have in the midfield. Am i better off to wait until next week knowing Crouch doesnt go up in price until the week after, but Mitchell goes up after this round so might make a few bucks, or wont Mitchells price increase because he scores have been so low???

bensl

he has a be of 46 so if he is the sub again he prob will go down in price.

Mat0369

Kommer is the other one. Bargain basement, started as the sub against the Dees but was one of their best against the Crows.

Samm79

Goodes to the mids then a back line rookie is another option.