JPK?

[Madsnake]

Not too bad first two weeks but as everyone is, i'm also looking at changing a bit before the price rise, whether that change will be a cash change or a point change i'm not too sure, JPK is my main headache, not so much because he's been playing particularly shower but just whether or not he's worth his money at the moment and whether i should trade him for Moloney, pocket some cash and be in for a Rookie -> Premo trade in the next few weeks or get in Pendles and forget about Moloney, which seems silly at his price. I also don't really want to trade either of the West Coast boys because they're playing Melbourne and should both kill it, obviously not enough to make their break evens but score is as important as cash, if not more.

Here's my team: WEAGLES

Cash Remaining: $1,400

Back: God, Heppell, Hanley, Gibbs, Goodes, Pittard (Stevenson, Terlich)

Mid: GAJ, Watson, JPK, Scooter, Embley, Wines, O'Meara, Viney (Crouch, Mitchell)

Ruck: Cox, Griffen (Currie, Blicavs)

Fwd: Rocky, Bartel, Rioli, Bolton, Kennedy, Karnezis (Neade, Macaffer)

Bold = Possible Liabilities, Bold and Underlined = Definite Liabilities

Give me your thoughts and your votes and if i value your opinion enough i'll give you a cheer or two.

[fertalong]

I would say that scooter is more of a liability than JPK. Im confident that JPK will come good.
I would go Scooter to Pendles if you want points (since your midfield is quite weak), and Scooter to Moloney for value + cash

[S_Coach99]

Karni -> Dwyer, JPK -> Other Premo/Option (specify Below)

Scott Selwood.

JPK is a better SC pick, but I'd keep JPK over Selwood too.

Mitchell you can ditch for Crouch maybe next week, I'm hoping Mitchell doesn't get subbed so he at least gets his break even of a whopping great 27. Who knows - might even crack a ton if he gets a full game  :P

[Madsnake]

I don't think i will end up Keeping either of the two, but seeing as Scooter has an excellent draw for the next few weeks i think i will keep him.

I think now it is just a decision of getting in Moloney or Pendles for JPK

[dillez]

id take money moloney and then turn scooter into pendles later  8)

[Madsnake]

id take money moloney and then turn scooter into pendles later  8)

You're a genius.

[dillez]

id take money moloney and then turn scooter into pendles later  8)

You're a genius.

Ha ha I just realised you have the same team name is me!! haha

only thing i am concerned with is you dont have too many premo's generating points, maybe pendles now might be a good idea, or just hope moloney keeps it up.

[powersuperkents]

Don't drop JPK, he's a POD some games he'll get 80-100 and then other games he'll get 140-170. It's only been two games, surely there's more important trade like dropping Kane Mitchell?

[Andrew]

Don't drop JPK, he's a POD some games he'll get 80-100 and then other games he'll get 140-170. It's only been two games, surely there's more important trade like dropping Kane Mitchell?

Yeah I'm just about wanting to see if he scores better against a better side. Another reason why I'm keeping him is that he's only looking at a small price decrease first week, and then I'm every chance of just dropping him to Crouch on the bubble if Kennedy doesn't go 100+

Less stoppages in games means less chance for a clearance player like Kennedy to slut up, that's something I'm looking for with premo midfielders but that being said it hasn't hurt Mitchell's scoring one bit...