Who makes way for JJK?

[Sweetness]

Here's the options

1) Karny --> JJK    (JJK has a good run coming up, will rise $50k this week)
2) K. Mitchell --> M.Jones (Jones will rise $50k, compared to not much by Mitchell)
Total Value= $100k

OR.

1) Robbo --> JJK (Dont get Robbo's -$40k and do get JJK's +$50k)
2) K.Mitchell --> Moloney (Moloney set to rise $40k)
Total Value = $130

However with Option 2, I will want to go Karny --> Robbo the next week (I still think he's a top FWD)
And this will be touch and go with $$

Thoughts appreciated

[Andrew]

Tough call, Kennedy is a must to bring in I feel. Playing Melbourne this week so 100+ on the way means a great score from a mid-priced forward with a $50k plus rise.

I like option 2, because Moloney is a great pickup also and Matt Jones is far from a must-have rookie anyway. Robbo can be brought back in, if/when he hits some form. But playing Geelong this week, the hard opponents just don't stop coming.

Karnezies is not the worst to hold but if he's sub again this week, you know what to do...

[Toga]

Imo Robbo is a keeper, hold on to him :) He will pump out some 100-120's before long :)

Option 1 for me: David Rodan was on 5AA last week and said Matty Jones has already impressed coaches and staff at the Dees and has overtaken a lot of players at the club... Reckon he will be a regular this season, should net you a bit of cash to start the season with :)

But both options are solid; would you definitely have enough cash to get Robbo in next week if you trade him out?

[Windigo]

I like option 2.

Jones isn't a must have rookie.

[mikeg12]

im in the same boat as im sure many others are, i hadnt even thought about that option 2 trade.  ill be doing that i reckon, good option there!

[Windigo]

I'm actually doing the same! Didn't realize.  :P

[bob321]

Option 2 is exactly what I'm planning for this week.
Just wondering if I'm better off going mitchell > moloney or mitchell > whitfield
either would be my m5

[Windigo]

Moloney surely!

[Sweetness]

Cheers for the replies guys!

At this stage I'll go Option 2 unless Karny looks like getting vested. It has the bonus of extra points with Molony replacing Viney on field in the mids.

Will wait til teams are announced as always...

[Windigo]

I'm playing you this week. I Hope the trades backfire!  :P

[Sweetness]

I'm playing you this week. I Hope the trades backfire!  :P

Well in that case, I predict another 177 for JJK and if Moloney comes in at least a lazy 150 hehe
Best of luck  :D

[Windigo]

Haha.  :P

I've worked it out, if I do the same trades as you, we we will only have 5 POD's... :o

[Sweetness]

You must have a good team then  :P

[Colliwobblers]

Here's the options

1) Karny --> JJK    (JJK has a good run coming up, will rise $50k this week)
2) K. Mitchell --> M.Jones (Jones will rise $50k, compared to not much by Mitchell)
Total Value= $100k

OR.

1) Robbo --> JJK (Dont get Robbo's -$40k and do get JJK's +$50k)
2) K.Mitchell --> Moloney (Moloney set to rise $40k)
Total Value = $130

However with Option 2, I will want to go Karny --> Robbo the next week (I still think he's a top FWD)
And this will be touch and go with $$

Thoughts appreciated

i like option 1. but not jones, get crouch unless you already have him?  kilss two birds with one stone and Robbo should prove a keeper.

with the number of trades we have, making cash is far less important as we will have SO many opportunities to trade and profit.

i reckon early on try get the best scoring bunch on your team.

[Windigo]

Haha, it will should be a close game.  8)